Year: 1991
Type: article
Abstract: Various formal and informal literacy assessment measures are described and evaluated.Specifically, the extent to which such measures reflect or distort the literacy performance of students from diverse linguistic, cultural, and/or economic background is noted.Although a flexible approach to assessment-giving teachers the freedom to situate or contextualize assessment--is supported, teachers in particular and educators in general are warned that they need to increase their knowledge base about language, culture, and literacy.Specific recommendations for changes in assessment practices and policies are delineated, and a list of criteria is presented for educators to use in creating and evaluating literacy assessment measures. LITERACY ASSESSMENT IN A DIVERSE SOCIETYConstructivist views of comprehension have dominated our thinking about reading since the early 1980s.The rhetorical trilogy of reader, text, and context is played out almost daily in education journals, state curriculum guides, basal reader philosophy statements, and methods textbooks.Along with the constructivist view of reading has come a call for assessment measures that focus on how readers construct meaning (see Pearson & Valencia, 1987;Wixson, Peters, Weber, & Roeber, 1987).Among reading educators, process has replaced product as the primary focus for assessment, bringing into question the wide range of performance measures that have dominated the reading field for the last 40 years.Interestingly, in their pursuit of alternative measures, several reading researchers are beginning to take on an "emic" or insiders' view perspective regarding assessment (Johnston, 1989) that until recently was the purview of qualitative sociologists, educational anthropologists, and sociolinguists (Cicourel, 1974;Ogbu, 1982;Troike, 1984).This shift in orientation toward understanding how individuals within a culture construct and interpret meanings has led to the realization that all performance measures, even those with the most impeccable reputations for objectivity, are inherently interpretive; at the very least, they reflect the values, norms, and mores of the test writers who developed them and of the educators and politicians who requested or authorized them.It also has caused some educators to reject the "sorting" and "gatekeeping" functions of many of the commercially produced assessment measures (for a historical account, see Karier, 1972).Increasingly, the rhetoric of the field calls for assessments that tell us how students approach, monitor, and process text.Critics of the conventional wisdom call for classroom-based assessment that is useful to the teachers and students involved (Goodman, Goodman, & Hood, 1989;Johnston, 1989;Resnick, 1989;Valencia, McGinley, & Pearson, 1990).While these developments may be positive for the field of reading, new forms of assessment will not, in and of themselves, improve the education of students from diverse linguistic, cultural, and economic backgrounds.Such an improvement requires a new multicultural awareness among educators in general and reading educators in particular.They must confront the legacy of three-quarters of a century of racism and discrimination inherent in literacy assessment.They must understand how tests (and, for that matter, many forms of classroom-based assessment) have been used, albeit not always intentionally, to blame students' diversity (themselves, their families, or their communities) for their lack of growth in school-based literacy.They must understand that schools, programs, and teachers contribute to the failure many students experience in acquiring these literacy skills.Without this awareness, it is possible that new assessment measures, even those based on a constructivist view of reading, even those that "empower" teacher decision making, will hinder rather than aide students' literacy development.* engage students in authentic literacy tasks Gardfa & Pearson Garcia & Pearson Literacy Assessment -16 * reflect a constructivist view of reading and writing * reveal student progress over time * emphasize what students can and cannot do (with and without help from the teacher, other adults, or their peers) * take advantage of rather than ignore or, even worse, penalize students' diversity * provide multiple indices of students' literacy development and interests * acknowledge students' interpretations (i.e., their "readings") of literacy tasks * encourage the involvement of students, parents, and community participantsWithout these characteristics, "new" methods of assessment will be no more useful to a diverse society than the "old" methods.
Authors: Georgia Earnest García, P. David Pearson
Institution: University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
Language: English
Subfield: Developmental and Educational Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1008848042
