Year: 2004
Type: article
Abstract: As genre theories are applied to research sites across professional and academic settings, more researchers are identifying a need to develop reliable accounts of not only the relative stability of genres, but also the range of variation across generic texts. While researchers have long maintained that genres and their textual instantiations are not fixed, but rather stable-for-now configurations of formal features open to improvisation, renewal, and change, studies still tend to foreground a fair degree of stability within genres at the particular moments when investigations have occurred. In an effort to better understand the range of creative generic strategies open to users, the power they offer users, and the circumstances in which they work, the present study examines a case in which a genre user both conforms to the stable generic expectations of a given situation and creatively manipulates his generic resources to redirect the flow of discourse to his advantage. In particular, the present study examines the final phase of the Bohr-Einstein dialogue, in which Niels Bohr answers a challenge co-authored by Albert Einstein with a text that is, at once, generic enough to pass as a legitimate reply to Einstein and filled with unconventional generic forms borrowed from a neighbouring sphere of scientific activity. The borrowed generic forms in Bohr's reply are examined in terms of their role in providing Bohr with a coherent, innovative generic strategy through which he is able to reconfigure the perceived rhetorical situation at hand and prompt readers to rethink Einstein's challenge on Bohr's terms. While genre theorists warn that this kind of innovative generic strategy can confuse readers, the present study clearly demonstrates the power available to those able to marshal their generic resources to not only resyo~ld to a rhetorical situation, but take control of it. Bohr's success with this particular strategy, however, seems to have hinged on two things: a readership able to recognize and willing to accept Bohr's use of unconventional forms in his reply to Einstein; and Bohr's own reputation in the scientific community, which allowed him the leeway to play with the generic conventions of the community. TABLE OF CONTENTS Approval ii ... Abstract III Table of
Source: Summit (Simon Fraser University)
Author: Rebecca Carruthers
Language: English
Subfield: Linguistics and Language
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W10320239
