Work

Allegories of Awakening: Melancholy, repetition and "race" in Charles Chesnutt's The House Behind the Cedars

Year: 2005
Type: book-chapter
Abstract: the nineteenth century become customary to criticize allegory.Writing to George Washington Cable, who acted as Chesnutt's intermediary, Gilder complained about a brutality in the characters, & a lack of mellowness, lack of spontaneous, imaginative life in the people, lack of outlook [...] that makes themas here depicteduninteresting [...].The result seems to me a crude story, not a thoroughly humane one [...].The hero & heroine are such frauds both of them that they have no interestas here described.The black boy is better, from a literary point of view [...].(McElrath & Leitz 67, emphasis in the original)Although Gilder located the failure less in the conception of the characters than in their realization, Chesnutt had his doubts about the significance of this distinction, not without justification perhaps, given Gilder's approval of the "black boy."Chesnutt was of course aware of the saturation of the post-Reconstruction public sphere with typifying and largely negative representations of black people, 1 and from his point of view, the failure of his manuscript was the result of his refusal to conform to conventional standards of representation.To him the black characters that white readers found convincing were obvious stereotypes, allegories of "dog-like fidelity and devotion" (McElrath & Leitz 65), while what he considered life-like portrayals struck his white readers as artificial and inauthentic.Responding to Gilder's enumeration of the shortcomings of his characters, Chesnutt insisted, in a letter to Cable: I fear, alas! that those are exactly the things that do characterize them, and just about the things that might be expected in themthe very qualities which government and society had for 300 years or so labored faithfully, zealously, and successfully to produce, the only qualities which would have rendered life at all endurable to them in the 19 th century.(McElrath & Leitz 66) Chesnutt, in other words, located the pressure that tended to make his black characters look lifeless and crude in the eyes of his white audience, in the conditions that the history of slavery had bequeathed to the era of segregated identities, which as a writer he confronted in the typifying form of allegory.Gilder's criticism provided the basis for Chesnutt's revisions of the "Rena Walden" project in subsequent years, not least because he continued to encounter it in one form or another throughout the 1890s, whenever he submitted the rewritten manuscript for publication.2 As a consequence, his efforts concentrated on making his characters mellower, endowing them with greater imaginative life, while striving to 1 The pervasively negative representation of black people in the post-Reconstruction era is wellknown.See, for instance, Gates ("The Trope of a New Negro" 339-40). 2 The history of the rejections of the "Rena Walden" manuscript prior to its publication as The House Behind the Cedars in 1900 is documented in Chesnutt's correspondence.After Gilder, Houghton, Mifflin also rejected the manuscript both as a short story for the Atlantic (1890) and as part of a book (1891).In 1895, Chesnutt again approached the Century with the rewritten story, but Gilder dissuaded him from resubmitting the manuscript.In 1898, the story caught the interest of Walter Hines Page of Houghton, Mifflin, who advised Chesnutt on its revision and expansion into a novel, but in 1899 Houghton, Mifflin rejected the manuscript again, reiterating some of Gilder'
Author: O Heim
Language: English
Subfield: History
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1044453519
FWCI:
Cites: 9
Cited by:
Related to: 10