The cadence of accountability: Is the removal rate for naval officers in command leadership positions increasing?
Year: 2013
Type: dissertation
Abstract: In the past decade, personal misconduct has emerged as the predominant characteristic of Commanding Officers in the United States Navy who have been removed from their positions of leadership.With the intention of revealing the role that misconduct plays in removal from command positions, this exploratory study first examines whether there has been a significant increase in the annual removal rate of Naval Officers in command leadership positions over the time period of 2008-2012.Second, it analyzes the effects of multiple categorical variables drawn from both personal misconduct and professional behaviors.Factors studied are those that substantiate a superior Officer's loss of confidence in a subordinate Officer's ability to command.Further, whether or not the factors serve as grounds for removal from the position of leadership thereby influencing a given annual removal rate are evaluated.Using collated data from disparate sources, a nonrandom sample was generated consisting of 174 Commanding Officer removals from January 1, 2003 through March 31, 2013.This study indicates that Commanding Officers are being removed at a current rate that is twice that of five years ago.Further, Commanding Officers are significantly more likely to be dismissed from their positions after committing acts of personal misconduct rather than a demonstration of lack of professional ability.Finally, male Officers were significantly more likely to be removed from a leadership position than female Officers.This may result from the fact that there are far greater numbers of males than females in the Officer corps.This may also stem from fewer females being selected for command leadership positions or being less likely to engage in acts of personal misconduct iv than their male counterparts.The findings described in this paper are congruent with a slowly growing body of literature that is beginning to investigate the increasing trend.Based on the root causes for removal, the Department of the Navy can implement policies that are evidence-based. Such policies could reduce enterprise risk and aim to minimize the removal rate by refiningOfficer selection processes for command leadership positions.v ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS First and foremost, I would like to thank John Christian for his sage guidance and dedication to my learning through this endeavor.Second, I am grateful for the staff and faculty of the Georgetown Public Policy Institute who so willingly imparted their knowledge and assistance to provide each member of the student body with the quantitative and qualitative skills necessary to undertake this type of analysis.I would like to specifically recognize Kathy Kretman, Carolyn Hill, and Kerry Pace for their confidence in, and support of, me during my time at Georgetown.Third, I am indebted to my loyal teammate from a previous tour of duty, Denise "Sparky" Williams, who kindly assisted me in gathering information used to compile an original database from which to conduct this study.Finally, I am blessed each day with the unwavering support of my remarkable wife, Kimberly, our wonderful children (Camden, Kinsey, Amelia
Author: Aaron Wayne Dimmock
Institution: Georgetown University
Language: English
Topic: Military and Defense Studies
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
Funder: U.S. Department of Defense
OpenAlex ID: W106750977
