Work

'Doctors can't help much': the search for an alternative.

Year: 1999
Type: article
Abstract: SUMMARY Background. At a time of great scientific advance and a culture of evidence-based health care, there is increasing referral to and use of complementary therapies. An understanding of the meaning behind this paradox may usefully inform our orthodox practice. Aim. To investigate why people attend complementary practitioners. Method. Semi-structured interviews with a purposive sample of 20 people drawn from a study population of 176 people currently attending a variety of complementary practitioners in South West England. Data were collected and analysed using a constant comparative method. Results. Most people had a chronic health problem, had already consulted their general practitioner (GP), and had their GP’s approval for seeking complementary therapy. Many people were attending a complementary therapist for the first time and most were fee-paying patients. People’s reasons for consulting were encompassed by three categories. The commonest of these is ‘Doctors can’t help much’, and the other two are ‘Doctors are hopeless’ and ‘It (orthodox medicine) may work but it’s not acceptable.’ The hopes and aims for treatment included long-term or shortterm symptom relief, improvement in function, better understanding, advice on self-help or other therapies, gaining control, and improving their ability to cope with their illness. Some people’s main aim was to avoid or reduce orthodox steroid-based medication. Conclusion. These people were seeking out holistic and patient-centred health care, and were making their own judgements about what constituted an acceptable level of risk from medication use. The advances of scientific medicine and expert evidence-based advice were not always relevant to them.
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W110299067
FWCI: 3.011
Cites: 22
Cited by: 43
Related to: 9