Work

Establishing probable cause in cerebral palsy. How much certainty is enough?

Year: 2000
Type: article
Abstract: Editor—The thesis set out by Little in 1862 that cerebral palsy was primarily due to perinatal cerebral injury did not meet with approval from the London Obstetrical Society—it was an obvious conflict of interests.1 Almost 14 decades later the echoes of those opposing voices still resonate, most recently in a statement from a group calling itself the International Cerebral Palsy Task Force.2 This statement makes some useful points, but there are aspects that need further debate. One is the need to recognise that it is usually possible to form a view on what caused cerebral palsy only in probabilistic terms. The question then is, how much certainty is enough? In the medicolegal context the answer is clear—more than 50% certainty (that is, P<0.5). It is irrelevant that birth asphyxia causes cerebral palsy rarely and that cerebral palsy is due to birth asphyxia rarely, as long as it is accepted that cerebral palsy is caused by birth asphyxia sometimes. In that case, when confronted with a case of cerebral palsy that could be due to birth asphyxia and in which there is evidence of birth asphyxia of potentially damaging severity, the relevant question to ask is, are these events probably causally related or are they probably coincidental? The answer is that they are more likely to be causally related, as long as no better explanation for the cerebral palsy is forthcoming. Secondly, insisting that there is a certain severity of metabolic acidaemia before attributing cerebral palsy to birth asphyxia is unreasonable. Such evidence might be necessary to form a view that approaches certainty (for example, P<0.05), but it is not necessary to form a view “on the balance of probabilities.” For instance, if a baby is stillborn after placental abruption, responds to heroic resuscitation, experiences an acute neonatal encephalopathy, and then develops athetoid cerebral palsy with evidence of basal ganglia injury shown by a magnetic resonance imaging scan, then birth asphyxia is the probable cause of disability regardless of whether metabolic acidaemia was found. This insistence on ascertaining metabolic acidaemia is questionable—cord blood gas analysis is not universally practised; if cord venous blood is obtained severe fetal acidaemia may be missed; bicarbonate is often used during resuscitation; and it will discourage the assessment of acid-base status at birth.
Source: PubMed
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W118890069
FWCI: 0.978
Cites: 3
Cited by: 11
Related to: 9