Work

A Constructivist Exploration of the Teacher's Role: understanding the policy practice navigation between: Pedagogy, Professionalism & Vocationalism

Year: 2010
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This constructivist grounded theory study, explores the role of the second level\nteacher in contemporary Ireland. It investigates how the officially espoused role of\nthe teacher translates into action in the negotiated environments of practice.\nThe study yielded three significant constructs that penetrate the reality of a\nteaching life. The three constructs emerged organically from an analysis of\nresearch-participant reflections regarding their practice as teachers. These three\ninterwoven constructs provide the scaffolding for the grounded theory findings:\ni. pedagogy under pressure,\nii. teachers navigating a pathway between old and new professionalism\niii. vocationalism and pockets of wonderful things\nWhile each of the three constructs has its own discourse and associated web of\nmeaning, there is also evidence of an over arching climate that weaves its influence\nacross the playing out of each. This climate is identified as one of intensification.\nThe intensification of teaching and learning significantly impacts on the teacher’s\nrole. The first of the three constructs; pedagogy under pressure emerges as a\nparticularly problematic one. The implicitly instrumentalist vision driving the\npractice of education (emergent in the first construct) compromises not only\nprogressive pedagogy, but also compromises the enactment of new professionalism\nas illuminated in the second construct. The intensification of education can also\nendanger the vocational impetus for teachers and render into ‘pockets’ the\n‘wonderful things’ that sustain and nurture the teacher’s ontological identity as\nprofiled in the final construct.\nThe qualitative findings suggest that the teacher’s role is therefore an increasingly\ncomplex one that navigates within and across three interwoven domains of what it\nmeans to be a teacher. Within this navigation, there is significant evidence of\npolicy practice dissonance, and localised negotiations of policy rhetoric, driven by\nthe imperative of terminal assessment. The study concludes that this climate of\nintensification militates against the realization of the more nurturing aims of\neducation espoused in the Government White Paper Charting Our Education\nFuture (1995).\nThe study provides educational policy makers, teacher educators and teachers with\nan insightful road map with which to interrogate many assumptions regarding\nsecond level teaching. The study interrogates policy, practice and theoretical\nperspectives. It raises many challenging questions regarding the teacher’s role and\nthe current instrumentalist vision driving the practice of second level education in\nIreland. These questions, findings and associated recommendations now deserve\nprompt study from teachers, teacher educators, policy makers and other educational\nstakeholers.
Author: Michael F. Ryan
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W129852416
Cites: 193
Cited by: 9
Related to: 10