Year: 2003
Type: article
Abstract: This case study evaluates and recommends improvements to the adaptive management programs within Washington State forest policy.I focus on the Watershed Analysis program, 1992 to 1997, a program for cooperative landscape assessment and forest practices rule-making at the watershed scale.However, 1 also take a longer-term history of Washington State forest policy, from 1987 to 2001, as essential context for understanding the functioning and outcomes of Watershed Analysis as a tool for social learning.I use the concepts of complex adaptive systems theory as a heuristic for understanding program and context as an integrated social system.My findings put in question the value of science-based management and formal program design -called "scientific adaptive management" -as a means of improving social learning in complex cases.The case history demonstrates that, given time and some basic formal arrangements, remarkable policy learning can also arise from informal and ad-hoc processes.The relevant dynamics include social processes that span many more levels of social structure than can be captured in a formal system.Complex adaptive systems theory captures many social realities that the scientific adaptive management model neglects.However, this heuristic provides only limited help in developing concrete recommendations for policy action.Ultimately, we need the insights provided by both perspectives on adaptive management, as well as the many other perspectives that exist.Perhaps most important is that adaptive managers develop a large store of policy ideas and arenas that provide adaptive capacity -a set of alternative mechanisms and "lenses" that can be deployed as appropriate to assess, probe, and work with the novel conditions of complex problems.Recent events in the case of Washington State forest policy constitute a movement towards the scientific adaptive management model, with a dramatically more formal and rigorously specified process for policy feedback and social learning.While the hazards of this approach are laid out in my study, the social networks of the policy domain may also learn a great deal by collectively undergoing this high-level trial.They have already learned plenty from the fascinating trials of the period that I analyze here.
Source: Summit (Simon Fraser University)
Author: Mark Kepkay
Language: English
Topic: Forest Management and Policy
Subfield: Forestry
Domain: Life Sciences
SDG: Life on land
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W130006677
