Studio prospettico randomizzato di confronto fra due tecniche per la sospensione dell'apice vaginale: miorrafia alta degli elevatori vs colposospensione ai legamenti utero sacrali alti: valutazione anatomo-clinica e l'impatto sulla qualità di vita
Year: 2008
Type: dissertation
Study designs: Randomized Controlled Trial, Clinical Trial
Abstract: Hypothesis / aims of study \nThe primary objective of this prospective randomized study is to evaluate the anatomical efficacy and the safety of two different transvaginal techniques for suspension of the superior vaginal segment in patients with Pelvic Organ Prolapse (POP) > stage 2: High Levator Myorraphy (HLM) (1) and Uterosacral Vaginal Vault Suspension (UVVS) (2). The secondary objective is to define the impact of these procedures on anorectal function, sexuality and Quality of Life (QoL)\nStudy design, materials and methods\nBetween September 2005 and December 2006, 116 female patients were enrolled. The pre-operative work-up included: history, POP-Q score, Q-Tip test, conventional urodynamic studies and questionnaires (King’s Health Questionnaire, Wexner score for constipation, and a Sexuality score). \nThe patients were randomized into two groups (computer generated randomization list): in the first group we used the HLM procedure for vaginal vault suspension ; in the second group the UVVS was performed. All the patients underwent correction of cystocele with a Polypropylene mesh applied “tension-free” and vaginal hysterectomy.\nThe results were analyzed using: T-test, McNemar Chi-squared test and Mann-Whitney U test. We considered p<0.05 as statistically significant. \nResults\nThe groups were matched for age, parity and menopausal status.\nThe demographic characteristics of both groups are reported in Table 1\n\nTable 1 – Demographic characteristics of both groups\n\tHLM\tUVVS\tP*\nPatients (#)\t58 \t58 \t0.18\nAge\t50-78 years (mean 66.3),\t45-78 years (mean 60.2),\t0.25\nParity\t0-4 (median 2)\t1-8 (median 2)\t0.97\nMenopause \t54 patients (93.1%)\t48 patients (82.8%)\t0.08\nBody Mass Index\t20.31-35.56 (mean 26.2)\t20-34.25 (mean 25.98)\t0.49\n* Mann Whitney U test\n \nThere were no significant pre-operative differences between the two groups regarding storage and voiding symptoms, urodynamic parameters and grade of prolapse.\nPre and post-operative symptoms are reported in Table 2 for HLM and UVVS groups \n\nTable 2 – Post-opeartive symptoms in both groups\n\tLM\n# (%)\tUVVS \n# (%)\tP*\nIncreased daytime frequency\t13 (22.4%)\t23 (39.7%)\t0.18\nUrgency\t21 (36.2%)\t25 (43.1%)\t0.57\nUrge urinary incontinence\t18 (31.1%)\t25 (43.1%)\t0.38\nNocturia\t12 (20.7%)\t17 (12.1%)\t0.57\nHesitancy\t4 (6.9%)\t6 (10.3%)\t0.61\nSlow stream\t17 (29.3%)\t14 (24.1%)\t0.75\nFeeling of incomplete emptying\t3 (5.2%)\t9 (15.5%)\t0.37\nDyspareunia\t13 (22.4%)\t16 (27.6%)\t0.13\nConstipation\t15 (25.9%)\t13 (22.4%)\t1\nHeaviness\t4 (6.9%)\t5 (8.6%)\t0.61\n* McNemar Chi-square test\n\nIn Table 3 anatomical results for HLM and UVVS groups are reported.\n\nTable 3 – Post-operative anatomical results for both groups\n\tLM\tUVVS \tP*\nPoint Aa > 2\t33 (56.9%)\t32 (55.2%)\t1\nPoint Ba > 2\t20 (34.5%)\t23 (39.7%)\t1\nPoint C > 2\t2 (3.4%)\t1 (1.7%)\t0.47\nPoint Bp > 2\t5 (8.6%)\t2 (3.5%)\t1\nTotal Vaginal Length\tMean 7.2 cm\tMean 8.9 cm\t0.04\n* McNemar Chi-square test\n\nPost operative Urodymanics data are reported in Table 4\n\nTable 4 – Post-operative urodynamics data in both groups\n\tHLM\tUVVS\tP\nFirst desire\nto void\t46-232 ml\n(mean 120.1, SD 72.21)\t30-347 ml\n(mean 136.69, SD 71.91)\t0.29*\nMaximum \nBladder capacity\t250-644 ml\n(mean 378.4, SD 78.87)\t191-481 ml\n(mean 360.76, SD 72.31)\t0.33*\nPressure at\nMaximum flow\t12-60 cmH20\n(mean 25.2, SD 13.22)\t69.60 cmH20\n(mean 25.24, SD 811-92)\t0.99*\nMaximum flow\t4-25 ml/sec\n(mean 13.8,SD 4.52)\t1-40 ml/sec\n(mean 14.75, SD 9.18)\t0.64*\nDetrusor overactivity\t17 patients(29.3%)\t45 patients (76%)\t0.05**\nUrodynamic SUI \t4 patients (6.9%)\t7 patients (12.1%)\t1**\n* Mc Nemar Chi-square test\n** T test\n\n“De novo” Symptoms are reported in Table 5\n \nTable 5 – “De novo” symptoms\n\tLM\tUS\nStress urinary incontinence\t5 (8.6%) \t8 (13.8%)\nUrge incontinence\t0\t7 (12.1%)\nUrgency\t2 (3.3%)\t5 (8.6%)\nIncreased daytime frequency\t3 (5.2%)\t9 (15.5%)\nNocturia\t6 (10.3%)\t7 (12.1%)\nSlow stream\t11 (18.9%)\t5 (8.6%)\nFeeling of incomplete emptying\t2 (3.4%)\t2 (3.4%)\nDyspareunia\t5 (8.6%)\t5 (8.6%)\nConstipation\t7 (12.1%)\t8 (13.8%)\n \nQuality of life was significantly improved in almost all domains according to the King’s Health Questionnaire, with the exception of Personal Relationships in HLM group, and General Health Perception, Sleep and Severity Measures in UVVS group. \nIn the UVVS procedure, angulation of the left ureter with hydronephrosis was observed in 5 patients (8.6%) which was diagnosed in the immediate post-operative period and resolved after removal of the suture. No intra-operative complications occured in the HLM group. Vaginal mesh erosions were present in 12% of HLM group and 17% in UVVS group (p 0.34)\nInterpretation of results\nBoth procedures provide significant anatomical correction of all vaginal segments. However the correction of the anterior segment was less effective. A possible explanation for this finding could be that the vaginal axis is displaced caudally by vault suspension. An additional aggravating factor could be the tension free application of the mesh anteriorly without anchoring sutures which does not provide adequate contrast to the tension resulting from the central segment suspension. \nThe mean Total Vaginal Length is 7.2 cm in HLM and 8.9 cm in UVVS group (p 0.04), but this does not coincide with an improvement in sexuality, as demonstrated by incidence of post-operative dyspareunia.\nThere is a statistically significative improvement of the voiding symptoms, prolapse-related symptoms, with a good impact on the quality of life. \nConcluding message\nThis study demonstates that the two vaginal vault suspension techniques are equivalent regarding anatomy, function and QoL. UVVS has a higher incidence of major complications involving the higher urinary tract, which, in our opinion, is an important factor to consider when selecting the appropriate surgical procedure.\nThe recent introduction of trans-perineal techniques for the correction of central vaginal prolapse seems promising, and results of ongoing trials are eagerly awaited. \nReferences\n1.\tUrology (2000) 56 (suppl 6A ): 50- 54.\n2.\tAm J Obstet Gynecol (1993) 168(6pt1): 1669- 74
Author: Albert Mako
Language: Italian
Subfield: Urology
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W139089669
