Year: 2010
Type: article
Abstract: Reasons for this lack of research include the sensitivity of the subject, difficulty gaining access to records, and the inherent difficulty in quantifying elder self-neglect.Other challenges to research of self-neglect include diagnosis, recruitment and retention of participants, attrition, non-standardized research language, and obtaining informed consent from subjects (Fulmer, 2008).Additionally, attempting to determine elder selfneglect gives rise to a number of difficult conceptual, identification and intervention problems for health and social care workers (Kelly, et al, 2008;Lauder, Anderson, and Barclay, 2005).This literature review focused on four areas of interest identified in the research questions of this Adult Protective Service study: conceptualizing elder selfneglect, assessing elder self-neglect, treating elder self-neglect, and honoring selfdetermination in cases of elder self-neglect.A brief historical overview of U.S. federal and Ohio elder protection systems is presented first. Overview of Federal and Ohio Elder Protection SystemsKohn (2009) provides the following overview of the federal U.S. elder protection system.In 1953, the American Public Welfare Association (APWA) formally identified a need for protective services for physically or mentally challenged adults.In the next twenty years, federal legislation was passed to fund demonstration projects to provide HONORING SELF-DETERMINATION IN CASES OF ELDER SELF-NEGLECTThe NASW Code of Ethics mandates that social workers should make every effort to foster maximum self-determination on the part of clients.This raises the question of how to define and foster self-determination in cases of elder self-neglect.To explore this question, APS workers interviewed for this dissertation were asked -How do you distinguish between elders' self-determination and self-neglect?‖Balancing seniors' legal right to refuse care with workers' professional responsibility to provide or link to needed care is an ongoing and international ethical dilemma.Ballard (2010) describes this dilemma as faced by Irish public health nurses:-Possession of a clear legal framework for the local area that addresses both the nurse's professional responsibility and the client's rights is needed.Because a high incidence of depression and dementia seen in self-neglecting adults has prompted calls for wider screening of the agreeable client, an understanding of the definition of competence and capacity in the national legal system for that client becomes critical.In Ireland, as in many other countries, refusal of care of screening is the right of any competent adult.However, issues of mandatory reporting, confidentiality, and trespass may differ from other areas.Nursing care delivered at the community level to a client exhibiting self-neglecting behavior involves a delicate balance of trust and support.‖(Ballard, 2010, p. 181) Like self-neglect, self-determination is a subjective concept.Simons and O'Brien (1999) proposed that self-determination depends upon one's knowing oneself and being able to do for oneself and others.They believe that a client's decisions can be accepted as informed, rational, and responsible if the following three prerequisites are met: The ability to understand the diagnoses, alternative treatments available, and their prognoses The ability to relate personal values, commitments, loyalties, and interests to the medical data given The ability to communicate one's decision based upon awareness of alternatives available, personal desires, and their consequences.
Author: Walter Brian Bohl
Institution: The Ohio State University
Language: English
Topic: Elder Abuse and Neglect
Subfield: Geriatrics and Gerontology
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1434314660
