Parenting and Child Mental Health: The Role of Openness in Internationally Adoptive Families
Year: 2009
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: This study examined the relationships among parenting behaviors, communicative openness, and child mental health in a sample of 67 two-parent, internationally adoptive families.Four hypotheses were tested: (1) parenting quality would be negatively related to child mental health problems; (2) parenting quality would be positively related to child openness during adoptionrelated conversations; (3) child openness would be negatively related to child mental health problems; and (4) the association between parenting quality and child mental health problems would be mediated by child openness.Certain parenting behaviors significantly predicted both child mental health problems and openness, but mediation was not supported.These findings should be considered in the development of resources for internationally adoptive parents aimed at promoting child mental health. Parenting 3Parenting and Child Mental Health: The Role of Openness in Internationally Adoptive Families Internationally adopted children are commonly thought to be at risk for a variety of psychological and behavioral problems.A national survey by the Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute showed that 52% of Americans saw international adoptees as more likely to have emotional problems than children adopted domestically in the United States (as cited in Freeark, 2006).One-third of respondents saw adopted children in general as more likely to have difficulties than their non-adopted peers.These pessimistic views persist, despite evidence that the vast majority of internationally adopted children function in the normal range (Juffer & van IJzendoorn, 2005;Wegar, 2000).Unfortunately, researchers approach international adoption with similar biases; much of the literature focuses on correlates and causes of poor outcomes.International and domestic adoption have been linked to insecure attachment, behavior problems, psychopathology, and academic difficulties (Feigelman, 2001;Irhammar & Bengtsson, 2004;Juffer & van IJzendoorn, 2005).Though these risks are important to consider, it is also wise to remember that there are over 32,000 international adoptions every year and most of these children are remarkably well adjusted (Freidlander et al., 2000;Juffer & van IJzendoorn, 2005;Selman, 2002).Upon close examination, much of the adoption research highlighting adoptees' various problems also confirms their typically normal development. Adoption and AttachmentBefore placement, internationally adopted children may be transferred from biological parents, to foster parents, to adoptive parents.Given that attachment relationships usually form by 8 or 9 months of age (Irhammar & Bengtsson, 2004), many researchers have been understandably concerned with attachment problems that may result from pre-adoption Parenting 4 instability.Findings have revealed problematic attachment in international adoptees under specific circumstances.For instance, Irhammar and Bengtsson (2004) studied adult attachment in a group of international adoptees and found that late adoption, memories from the time before adoption, divorce, lack of contact with the child's origin, and a tendency not to think about their biological background were associated with an unresolved/disorganized attachment status.Similarly, Cederblad, Hook, Irhammar, and Mercke (1999) found a connection between the amount of time a child spent in an orphanage and attachment problems.It seems that certain preadoption histories increase the likelihood of post-adoption attachment problems.However, as a group, internationally adopted individuals appear to be as securely attached as non-adopted controls.In the same study by Irhammar and Bengtsson (2004), adult adoptees did not differ significantly from non-clinical controls in attachment status, despite their high mean age of adoption (3 years).Such findings have been replicated with children; internationally adopted infants showed a distribution of secure and insecure attachment relationships similar to control groups, though they did show a higher incidence of disorganized attachment (van Londen, Juffer, & van IJzendoorn, 2007).Overall, children demonstrate an impressive adaptability to new caregivers.Secure attachments may buffer internationally adopted children against the development of later problems.According to Weinfield, Sroufe, Egeland, & Carlson (1999), children with secure attachment relationships have higher quality friendships, fewer conflicts, and are less likely to have behavior problems than children with insecure attachment relationships.Because international adoptees generally show normative rates of secure attachment, their later social and behavioral adjustment should not be compromised.Research supports high levels of social competence in internationally adopted children.Stams, Juffer, Rispens, and Hoksbergen (2000) Parenting 5 found that internationally adopted girls scored higher in ego control, social competence, and peer group popularity than non-adopted controls.Being internationally adopted in and of itself does not appear to be strongly predictive of attachment problems or consequential social difficulties. Adoption and Mental HealthThe overrepresentation of internationally adopted children in mental health services is well established (Brodzinsky, Schecter, & Henig, 1992;Juffer & Van IJzendoorn, 2005).However, research based on non-clinical samples of children consistently shows few or no differences in adjustment between adopted and non-adopted children (Haugaard, 1998).The differences that do appear may be the result of misleading study characteristics.For example, Juffer and van IJzendoorn (2005) performed a meta-analysis of over 25,000 cases and more than 80,000 controls and found that international adoptees showed significantly more total behavior problems, internalizing problems, and externalizing problems than non-adopted controls.However, using the same measure of behavior problems (CBCL) with a smaller sample, Cederblad et al. (1999) found no significant mental health differences between international adoptees and non-adopted controls.Several explanations for these contradictory findings have been suggested.The effect sizes found in the aforementioned meta-analysis were fairly small, but were able to reach statistical significance with such a large sample size.Researchers have argued that statistically significant findings evidencing international adoptees' problematic adjustment are often too small to be clinically meaningful (Freeark, 2006;Juffer & van IJzendoorn, 2005).These small differences in mean adjustment score may be the result of a small minority of international adoptees with severe problems.Haugaard (1998) shows that adopted children as a group can show poorer adjustment than non-adopted children due solely to a small minority of cases in a Parenting 6 sample.He argues that considering all subgroups of adopted children together may lead to statistics that overestimate the risk to some children and underestimate the risk to others.Control groups that are unrepresentative of the general population of non-adopted children can also lead to an overestimation of the risks associated with international adoption.Adopted youth are often compared only with non-adopted children who have grown up with two biological parents.Freeark (2006) suggests that such comparisons may be misleading, given that an analysis of a large national survey on adolescent health found that adolescents with divorced parents showed far greater adjustment problems than adopted adolescents living in two parents families (Feigelman 2001).Similarly, Fergusson, Lynskey, & Horwood (1995) found that adolescents from single-mother families showed more problematic adjustment than adopted adolescents.International adoptees have compared favorably to domestic adoptees as well.In the meta-analysis by Juffer and van IJzendoorn (2005), internationally adopted children presented fewer total behavior problems, internalizing problems, and externalizing problems than domestically adopted children.They were also less often referred for mental health services.This resilience was surprising to the authors who had hypothesized the reverse, given the higher rate of pre-adoption adversity for international adoptees.(Juffer & van IJzendoorn, 2005; Verhulst, Althus, & Versluis-Den-Bieman, 1990).So, homogenous control groups of particularly low-risk children may be the source of some studies' significant differences.Another explanation for the apparent mental health problems of internationally adopted individuals is referral bias.Both parents and professionals have been shown to have a lower referral threshold for adopted children than for biological children (Brodzinsky et al., 1998;Ingersoll, 1997;Miller et al., 2000).Normative developmental challenges for adopted children as they struggle with complex identity issues and adoption stigma and stereotypes may be
Author: Kayla Frick
Institution: University of Michigan
Language: English
Topic: Child Welfare and Adoption
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: international adoption, parenting quality, child mental health, attachment, insecure attachment, adoptive families, child adjustment, parenting resources, parental behavior, parenting practices, parenting attitudes, parenting knowledge, parenting skills, parental self-efficacy, parenting self-regulation
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W145627170
