Law's Limited Domain Confronts Morality's Universal Empire
Year: 2006
Type: article
Abstract: There is an ongoing debate in contemporary jurisprudence over whether law, properly conceived, is capable of incorporating morality.And this debate has its important practical analogues, especially in American constitutional law.For this is where lawyers and scholars argue about whether, for example, the guarantees of equal protection, freedom of speech, and the free exercise of religion, as well as the prohibitions on cruel and unusual punishments and unreasonable searches and seizures, require courts and other governmental decision makers to adhere to the correct moral principles regarding equality, freedom of speech, freedom of religion, punishment, and (locational) privacy.That these and other constitutional clauses appear to speak in moral language is relatively uncontroversial, but far more controversial is what it means for authoritative law to speak in moral language, and how, if at all, such language connects law with what is simply and prelegally morally right (and wrong) to do.These debates about the status of morality in legal argument are important, but our goal here is not to engage them frontally.Rather, we wish to illuminate a particular aspect of these debates.And that aspect is the logic of the incorporation by law of morality, t This paper was prepared for the Conference on Law and Morality, Institute of Bill of Rights Law, William & Mary School of Law, March 16-18, 2006.We thank the other participants and members of the audience for their helpful comments and criticisms.
Source: William and Mary law review
Authors: Larry Alexander, Frederick Schauer
Institutions: University of San Diego, University of Virginia
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1482760994
