The value of taking notes during lectures
Year: 1986
Type: article
Abstract: The conceptual frameworks of "levels of processing" and "transfer appropriate processing" were used to interpret the research literature on listening and notetaking.Based on these frameworks, implications for the encoding and external storage hypotheses about the functions of notetaking are presented and critiqued.We conclude that there is a potential benefit to students from the encoding function when the lecture situation permits deeper processing while taking notes and when students take the kind of notes that entail processing the information in the way they will need to use it on the criterion test.Also, students can benefit from reviewing notes when the notes contain the information that will be tested and when students process the information in a way similar to how it will be used on the criterion test.Taking Notes 3 The Value of Taking Notes During Lectures College students typically spend ten or more hours per week attending lectures.How can students make the most efficient use of that time?Is the time-honored suggestion to listen carefully and take good notes a sound one?If taking notes is helpful, how is it helpful?In 1910, educator Seward (1910) answered some of these questions in about the same way that many experts do today by proposing two functions of notetaking: Ask our friend, the average student, what is the use of taking notes, and he will answer without hesitation: Why, to preserve a record of what a lecturer has said, for the sake of future use, especially interviewing for examinations.(p. 1)Our notes should, indeed, be useful for purposes of review yet that usefulness is not their chief value.They should be full, yet contain only what the mind has accepted as significant.The practical value of our notes will take care of itself as a matter of secondary importance, if we devote ourselves wholly to their main purposes--to make us alert, clearheaded, and responsible as we listen to a lecture, and to serve as a ready test of the firmness of our grasp.(p.9)The two functions of notetaking identified by Seward approximately 75 years ago are still the hypothesized functions of notetaking.Today the hypotheses are commonly labelled Taking Notes "external storage" and "encoding."The "encoding" hypothesis suggests that the actual process of taking notes helps the notetaker learn and remember information; the "external storage" hypothesis postulates that the value of taking notes lies in preserving information for later use, such as review before an examination.Thus, the "encoding" and "external storage" hypotheses offer two opportunities for learning information from a lecture: once while listening and recording notes and again while reviewing or studying the notes prior to an examination.Recent theory and research in cognitive psychology suggest how taking notes on a lecture might affect learning at both the listening/"encoding" and reviewing/studying stages.The purpose of this paper is to review the research on taking notes during lectures from a cognitive psychology perspective and to draw implications for college instruction. A Perspective from Cognitive PsychologyWe have found the conceptual frameworks of "levels of processing" (Anderson, 1970(Anderson, , 1972;;Craik & Lockhart, 1972) and the related "transfer appropriate processing" (Morris, Bransford, & Franks, 1977) to be particularly useful in interpreting the research literature on listening and notetaking.(Bretzing & Kulhavy, 1979; and Kiewra, 1985a, have also used this framework to help conceptualize the effects of notetaking strategies.)We will first briefly describe these conceptual frameworks.Then we will discuss the implications of these ideas for the "encoding"Taking Notes 5and "external storage" hypotheses about the functions of notetaking.
Authors: Thomas H. Anderson, Bonnie B. Armbruster
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1483822678
