Work

The Anticompetitive Effects of Unenforced Invalid Patents

Year: 2006
Type: article
Abstract: sist the encroachment of antitrust law into the intellectual property arena.Antitrust advocates view with suspicion the potential exercise of market power by intellectual property owners in a manner that expands the legitimate power of a patent in an illegitimate way.While the vast majority of patents do not confer monopoly power, antitrust principles are implicated in those markets where monopolists do in fact maintain their dominant position through patents.Amidst the discord, relative consensus prevails in one area.Even supporters of strong patent protection have generally not quarreled with antitrust law's treatment of patents procured through fraud.The Sherman Antitrust Act (Sherman Act) 1 proscribes the use of invalid patents to secure a monopoly, and the patent system has little interest in protecting the ability of firms to acquire and enforce invalid patents. 2 But antitrust law's current treatment of invalid patents remains inadequate.While antitrust law recognizes that enforcing invalid patents can constitute illegal monopolization or attempted monopolization, courts have refused to consider the anticompetitive effects of simply having an invalid patent.This Article argues that, under certain circumstances, a monopolist's possession of a patent that it knows to be invalid, which it holds out to the world as valid, should violate the Sherman Act's prohibition on monopolization.Part One lays out the current state of the law regarding when the use of an invalid patent violates the Sherman Act.Invalid patents can give rise to antitrust liability when a monopolist commits fraud against the Patent Office or brings an infringement lawsuit based on a fraudulently procured patent.These are, respectively, the Walker Process and the Handgards theories of recovery.Under either cause of action, the antitrust plaintiff must show that the defendant actually enforced its invalid patent.Part Two argues that this current doctrine, by limiting liability to instances of actual enforcement of an invalid patent, is too constricted.Mere possession of an invalid patent can help maintain an illegitimate monopoly even if the monopolist patent-holder takes no affirmative steps to enforce its patent.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W148406245
FWCI: 9.598
Cites:
Cited by: 21
Related to: 10