The Torture Warrant: A Response to Professor Strauss
Year: 2003
Type: article
Abstract: Professor Strauss characterizes me as "figuring most prominently in [the] debate" over whether torture "would be justified to prevent mass casualties ... [the] 'ticking bomb scenario."' 1 She says that I have "seemingly advocated the use of torture in certain very limited circumstances." 2 In light of how much I have written about this issue, Strauss's use of the word "seemingly" is surprising.3 But at least she does not claim, as others have, that I advocate "circumventing constitutional prohibitions on torture," 4 that I have given "thumbs up to torture," that I have "proposed torture for captured terrorist leaders," 5 that I believe "U.S. agencies should be accorded the right to torture those suspected of withholding information in a terrorist case," 6 and that I "advocate ... shoving a sterilized needle under the fingernails of those subjects being interrogated."One reviewer has even called me "Torquemada Dershowitz," a reference to the notorious torturer of the Inquisition.7 No one, however, reminded readers that it was the liberal Jeremy Bentham who made the most powerful utilitarian case for limited torture of convicted criminals to gather information necessary to *
Author: Alan M. Dershowitz
Language: English
Topic: Torture, Ethics, and Law
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1489008772
