Work

Confronting climate crisis : a framework for understanding the criteria for addressing dangerous climate change

Year: 2011
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Despite wide acknowledgement of the threats from human-induced climate change to \nhuman societies and the wider ecosystem, no comprehensive long-term global agreement \nto tackle the problem has yet been reached to replace the Kyoto Protocol. In arguing for a \nreplacement, evaluative claims are often made that certain policy proposals are more \nenvironmentally effective, equitable or efficient than others. However, these three dominant \ncriteria are subject to a range of interpretations, and can come into conflict with one \nanother. This limits their use for guiding policy. Philosophy can and should play a role in \nscrutinising alternative conceptions, their justifications and assumptions, and help develop \njustifiable formulations of the criteria. Existing philosophical contributions have focused \non aspects of the equity criterion, but have largely overlooked the other two criteria and \nhave not considered how they should be prioritised overall. This thesis, for the first time, \nconsiders and proposes an ordering of these three criteria (focusing on mitigation), drawing \non a Green Economic conceptual framework. This places ecological effectiveness first, \ndefining the ecological limits of economic greenhouse gas-emitting activity; equity is then \napplied second, to define equitable resource sharing of the emissions space; and efficiency \nlast, to imply genuinely efficient use of emissions space in contributing to equitable human \nwell-being. The thesis then examines in detail how each criterion should be interpreted \nwithin this context, so that they are mutually consistent. As well as offering a set of ordered \nevaluative criteria for a climate change mitigation agreement, it aims to highlight the role \nof the conventional political-economic framework in climate policy debates and draw out \nthe hidden conceptual and ethical assumptions it imports. This thesis also, therefore, aims \nto further the development of Green Economic thinking and show its relevance to the \ncurrent substantial threat of dangerous anthropogenic climate change.
Author: Ruth Makoff
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1489654825
Cites: 190
Cited by:
Related to: 9