Work

Building the European Road Safety Observatory. SafetyNet. Deliverable D4.2 Database transparency

Year: 2006
Type: article
Abstract: Road transport and all road transport related industries are clearly very\nimportant to European economy and societies. In terms of impact to European\nemployment for instance, road transport is probably the most important\ntransport sector. On the other hand, the relatively poor road safety – accidents,\nthose killed and injured, material damage and other socio-economic costs –\nconstitutes a major socio-economic problem.\nWhile road safety has recently emerged as an issue on all political decisionmaking\nlevels, it was for a long time neglected compared to the issue of safety\nin the public transport modes, such as rail, air and maritime. This delay and the\nrequirement of independence for accident investigating entities in the public\ntransport modes result from the characteristics of different transport modes.\nIndependence of an investigation body is to be understood as a means of\nassuring its impartiality – and that of the investigations it conducts.\nHowever, the independence of the investigation body and processes do not\nresolve the question of the quality of investigations. The quality of the\ninvestigation work relies certainly on the impartiality of the investigating body\nand processes, but also on the qualifications and experience of the\ninvestigators, as well as the investigation methods they use. It is not\nindependence, but transparency that best describes these aspects of accident\ninvestigation. We shall define transparency as the availability of such relevant\ninformation on the accident investigation, which allow its quality to be assessed.\nIn this deliverable, we have applied the concept of transparency only to\ndatabases, but it does apply to all accident investigation results: data, case\nstudies or accident reports and any other subsequent data.\nInvestigation bodies frequently cooperate with similar bodies from other\ncountries or with other stakeholders (manufacturers, operators, regulators,\nconsumers etc.), for specific accident investigations, and such interrelations\nstrengthen their impartiality. In quite a similar manner, transparency can be\nfurther facilitated by the use of international methods and standards. The\nprocess of building a European road safety community through Commission\nsupported research programmes is important in creating interrelations between\nresearch institutes and in creating progressively a body of common European\naccident investigation methods, standards, data and knowledge.\nThe reviewed databases can roughly be divided in two categories. There are\nthe police collected data that, in spite of their drawbacks, have the advantage of\nbeing national. The percentage of under-reporting and under-recording can be\nquite consequent, but this is rather irrelevant when national statistics are used\nfor continued trend monitoring for instance. On the other hand there are the\nresearch oriented databases, whose uses are specific and depend on the\nresearch objectives. In some cases such databases might result for instance\nfrom legal obligations set for insurers, and might even contain police or other\nextensive data from certain areas and for longer periods. Other databases have\nbeen designed for a one-off use.\nDatabase transparency\nProject co-financed by the European Commission, Directorate-General Transport and Energy\nsn_inrets_wp4_d4.2_final_03/02/2006 Page 5\nAll the databases reviewed in this deliverable are, according to our evaluation,\ntransparent. In other terms, there is sufficient information available on all the\nrelevant aspects of these databases for assessing their actual quality. Making\nquality evaluations was not an objective of this work package and we have not\nproceeded to such quality evaluations. The principal reason for this is the fact\nthat databases cannot be evaluated against a single scale. They have been\ndesigned for answering specific questions and should be judged on the basis of\nhow well they reach that particular objective. The establishment of criteria for\nevaluating the transparency of accident investigation data (databases in this\ndeliverable) was in itself a challenging task. Nevertheless we felt it had to be\ncompleted by some considerations on the use of accident investigation data\nand the limits that should be set to transparency.\nThe only necessary limit that should be set to the transparency of accident\ninvestigation data is the right to privacy. Individual, identifiable accident level\ndata should not be made publicly available – unless such data is necessary for\nunderstanding the circumstances and the sequence of events in case of major\naccidents (like the public transport accidents frequently are).\nThere is another limitation to the transparency of accident investigation data,\nwhich results from the nature of that data. The investigation data is not just\n“observed” but is “constructed” according to specific, well-defined\nmethodological choices. The process of data gathering, which begins with the\nchoice of some particular pieces of information amongst a large number of\ndetails about an accident and ends with synthesized data, is a rather complex\nprocess and calls for specific qualifications and experience. The same is of\ncourse true –unfortunately perhaps – for appreciating the investigation results\nand participating to any debates about their scientific quality.\nWhile this limitation is real and has to be accepted, there is no need – quite the\ncontrary – to conceal information from the public. Transport safety in all\ntransport modes is an issue of public interest and adequate1 safety information,\nincluding accident investigation data, has to be publicly available. Sometimes\npublic will misinterprete some of the available data, which will need to be dealt\nwith. In any case, this would be a far lesser evil than having to constantly\nreassure the public that important safety related information is not being\nconcealed.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1490347451
FWCI: 0.989
Cites: 14
Cited by: 2
Related to: 9