El hombre de la edad glacial en suramerica : una perspectiva europea
Year: 1990
Type: article
Abstract: Europeans, more than Americans have long been inclined to accept a Paleo lithic period in South America, which would have occurred long before the sudden and obvious appearence, about 11,000 years ago, of Paleoindian hunters. Over the past ten years a pre-Clovis occupation of North America has segun to appear increasingly unlikely, but, at the same time, a number of North and South American archaeologists have joined with Europeans in arguing for an early, non-Paleoindian occupation of South America. This paper is an attempt to put the dispute about Early Man in South America in historical context, and to review the most convincing and important evidence that has been put forward. Essentially no Paleoindian skeletal remains, in North or South America have survived recent scrutiny and direct dating by AMS and small C02 counters. Only a handful of North American sites are still considered reasonably likely to be pre-Clovis, but the concept of an earlier, generalized hunting and gathering adaptation is still popular. South American sites purported in the 1969's and 1970's to be of pre-Paleoin dianage are re-evaluated and found to present only weak or negative indica tions of early occupations. Recently discovered sites in Brazil and Chile are critically examined and the evidence is questioned. The results of this survey and evaluation suggest that we still lack the absolutely certain case that would be necessary to demonstrate the hypothesis. Moreover, the statistical probability is seen to decrease, rather than increase, as the Paleoindian horizon is increasingly defined with more certainty while only equivocal cases are marshalled for Archaic-like, pre-Paleoindian stage. Archaeologists should depend more on the unambiguous and replicated cases, rather than regional exceptions, in writing the general patterns of America prehistory. A plea in made for more interpretive caution, especially where there were possibilities of mixture and secondary deposition. Natural processes often mimic cultural patterns, confusing the positive identification of amorphous hearths and simple artifacts.
Source: Revista de Arqueología Americana
Author: Thomas F. Lynch
Institution: Cornell University
Language: Spanish
Subfield: Anthropology
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W1492745506
