Work

Contested Terrains of Compensation: Equality, Affirmative Action and Diversity in the United States

Year: 1997
Type: article
Abstract: Equality is an elusive concept. Celeste Condit and John Louis Lucaites write that equality 'is at once a normative abstraction that resonates with the highest ideals of America's collective being, and a rather narrow and pedestrian, empirical characterisation of the sameness or identity of any two objects' (Condit and Lucaites, 1993: ix). In the United States the concept of equality is unstable and relatively indeterminate. 'The language of equality is rhetorical cover under which political claims are advanced and contested; but it very seldom captures the substance of those political claims' (Waldron, 1991: 1351). Therefore, some argue, the rhetoric of equality has no substantive content (Westen, 1982). Nevertheless, the rhetoric and public discourse surrounding discussions of equality influence legal interpretations of what constitutes compensatory justice. Given the indeterminacy of law, it is unsurprising that there are competing visions of equality in the United States today. The controversy in the United States over what constitutes equality for blacks or African Americans and other 'racial minorities' is one site of this debate. In fact, much of the current public discourse on affirmative action, for example, centres around the meaning of equality. Affirmative action is seen by proponents as a means to achieving a racially just society. Opponents argue, however, that affirmative action undermines equality between racialised groups because race can be used as a decision-making factor. This essay adopts the more cynical view advanced by some critical scholars, namely that affirmative action programs and anti-discrimination law in general are not designed to achieve a racially just society.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1500877995
FWCI:
Cites: 15
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10