Harmony And Its Functionality: A Gloss On The Substantial Similarity Test In Music Copyrights
Year: 2008
Type: article
Abstract: composition be deemed protectable under copyright law?This Article argues that it should not be, and offers a new paradigm for the reevaluation of the role harmony plays in the substantial similarity test.The Article contends that basic tonal harmonic progressions should be unprotectable as a matter of law because those progressions constitute a song's functional feature. 1 For example, a twelve-bar blues harmonic progression should be unprotectable not just because of the ubiquitous "public domain" argument, but because of the functional features the harmony possesses.2 The twelve-bar structure itself should be treated as a functional feature, because a composer may use the progression a dozen of times within one song to create the type of acoustic pattern listeners call "the blues."Mass consumers demand music capable of being emulated by a vast number of people, and they demand music in which simple harmony is a prominent trait.3 Protecting simple harmonic material of one composer would hinder the ability of other composers to produce songs with the features demanded by music 1 Cristle Collins Judd, Studies on the Origin of Harmonic Tonality by Carl Dahlhaus: Robert O. Gjerdingen, 74 MUSIC & LETTERS 61 (1993) (book review).Dahlhaus defines harmonic tonality as "the representation of a key by means of associations among chords related to a center."Id.; see also Carl Dahlhaus,
Author: Sergiu Gherman
Language: English
Topic: Intellectual Property Law
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1501196082
