Work

Conditions for the development of a product ecolabel

Year: 1999
Type: article
Abstract: Since the early 1990s, national ecolabelling programmes have proliferated worldwide. The European Union (EU) implemented such a regional progamme in 1991. This decision was part of a broader orientation towards an integrated product policy approach in the EU. Since 1991, the development of European ecolabels has been slow and difficult. This paper examines industrial strategies vis-à-vis the EU ecolabel in order to understand the problems faced by the regulator in the development of this ecolabel. Ecolabels offer firms the opportunity to signal to consumers which products are more respectful of the natural environment. The ecolabelling process consists of two consecutive phases. The first phase is a negotiation period between firms and the regulator; this is aimed at devising ecolabelling criteria. These criteria typically consist of a list of maximum thresholds of polluting emissions, which have to be met by a product in order to be eligible for the ecolabel. The second phase, a market phase, follows. During this phase the products that fulfil the requirements can be labelled as meeting the criteria and exchanged on the market. The first part of the paper defines and uses the concept of ‘credence good’ in order to argue that the consumer cannot assess the ecolabel. Based on the examination of the development of the European ecolabel, the second part points out three variables that seem to determine the outcome of the negotiation phase. We show that the strategies undertaken by industrial firms both during the negotiation and the market phases have varied. They ranged from co-operation across an entire industry (e.g. ecolabel for paints and varnishes) to a confrontation among industrial strategic groups (e.g. the ecolabel for detergents) or a frontal opposition to the development of the ecolabel (e.g. the ecolabel for cosmetics or for paper products). We then emphasize the influence of three variables in the determination of firms’ strategies: (i) the type of industry (i.e. the degree of heterogeneity between the sets of products sold by the different firms); (ii) the threat of direct governmental regulation on the environmental quality of the product and (iii) the magnitude of the final demand for a green variant of the product. The paper concludes with a discussion of policy implications for policy makers interested in considering or promoting the use of ecolabels. Copyright © 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd and ERP Environment. and ERP Environment.
Author: Alain Nadaï
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1503151603
FWCI: 3.179
Cites: 2
Cited by: 37
Related to: 10