Work

Integrating ecological impacts into evaluations of the effectiveness of environmental regimes: the example of CITES

Year: 2011
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The proliferation of multilateral environmental agreements has resulted in an increased\ninterest, from academics and others, in questions regarding the effectiveness of such\nagreements. Much if not all attention has focused on the institutional aspects of regime\nfunctioning, specifically behaviour change. Relatively less attention has been given to the\nactual ecological or biophysical aspects of regime effectiveness. The focus on institutional\neffectiveness is for sound reasons, such as challenges associated with incorporating\necological factors into any evaluation, measuring effectiveness, and establishing causality.\nHowever, these challenges do not diminish the importance of assessing ecological\neffectiveness and its relationships with institutional functioning. Does political, legal or\nbehaviour change consistently lead to improvement in environmental quality? Can it be\nassumed that “institutional effectiveness” is an accurate and appropriate proxy for\n“ecological effectiveness”? Are the challenges associated with using ecological data\ninsurmountable?\nThis thesis aims to advance understanding of the linkages between institutional and\necological effectiveness and to explore how an integrated assessment of both can be\nundertaken. Putting forward a model for an integrated assessment of institutional and\necological effectiveness, and using a mixed methods approach, this study analyses a\ncompliance mechanism under the Convention on International Trade in Endangered\nSpecies of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) as a case study to evaluate both the institutional\nand the ecological effectiveness of this regime, and how these are linked with variables\nthat may be intervening in the relationship.\nThe results suggest that, although CITES is widely considered to be institutionally\neffective, its ecological effectiveness is questionable. The discrepancy can, to a large\nextent, be explained by two main categories of intervening variables: the complexity and\nnature of the problem, and domestic or national-level factors. The integrated assessment\nuses ecological and quantitative data to help increase our understanding of the nature and\nextent of institutional and ecological effectiveness, and illuminates any gaps between\nthem. The analysis demonstrates that extending evaluations to include environmental\nimpacts can provide a more accurate picture of overall effectiveness of regimes, and offers\nresearchers and practitioners a basis for developing ideas and actions aimed at improving\nregime functioning.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1505221101
Cites: 179
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10