Work

Unity and Pluralism in Contract Law

Year: 2004
Type: article
Abstract: It is a cliche of contemporary legal scholarship that, in the last few decades, the study of law has witnessed a vast proliferation of competing theoretical approaches.The old faith in the careful honing of doctrinal concepts and the essential usefulness of legal analysis has given way to a cacophony of competing theoretical sects. 1 Economists, moral philosophers, sociologists, historians, and others have stepped forward to offer the insights of this or that discipline as a new and superior path to legal enlightenment.Perhaps nowhere has this cliche been truer than in the realm of contracts scholarship, where, for a generation, the competing disciplinary approaches have been energetically proselytizing for their chosen theories.Hence, modern legal scholarship abounds with economic, philosophical, and sociological theories of contract law.Most contracts scholars take one of two basic approaches.On one side stand those who, while acknowledging the usefulness of the new theoretical tools, remain unconverted to any of them.With lawyerly pragmatism, they remain skeptical of unifying theoretical enterprises.Human experience and the law are too complex for academic reductionism, they argue, and "a good gray compromise" of competing principles and policies 2 is the best that we can hope for.
Institution: William & Mary
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1514715354
FWCI: 11.04
Cites: 5
Cited by: 22
Related to: 10