Human-computer interaction : from classifying users to classifying users' misunderstandings
Year: 1989
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The overall objective of the research has been to address the question of how best to \nunderstand user behaviour at the interface. The use of cognitive grammars to analyse \ntasks and predict behaviour was rejected for seven theoretical and practical reasons. \nFollowing this, cognitive style measures were rejected as a result the first study, where \nthe visualizer-verbalizer and conceptual tempoc ognitive style measures were not found \nto be accurate predictors of behaviour at a task. The results of this experiment indicated \nthat interaction between a system and its user has certain dynamic qualities that make \nprediction of a fixed set of activities in a set order difficult. Furthermore, it seemed \nlikely that behaviour is determined by a potentially complex interaction of variables \nrather than any single over-riding factor, such as a user's cognitive style. \nConsequently, attention was-focused upon the errors that occur during humancomputerinteraction. \nAn approach where errors are classified was -adopted, and a classification scheme was developed (ECM: an Evaluative Classification of Mismatch)as a vehicle for further research. \nAn initial pilot study showed that user-system errors could be classified using the \nscheme. This suggested that the concepts it employed did have some validity in'both \ncognitive and computing domains. The second study of ECM involved a design team at \nHewlett Packard's Office Products division in Wokingham. This study demonstrated \nthat the classification scheme was - usable by a design and development team that \nconsisted of software engineers, human factors engineers, and technical authors. The \nthird and final study of ECM demonstrated that it could be, used to improve a design. A \nsystem, that had been changed using ECM, was shown to be significantly better, in \nterms of time, errors and user attitude ratings, than either its original or an iteration \nwhere ECM had not been employed. \nThis research has provided strong indications that evaluative classifications can be \nof use within the design and development process. Furthermore, this work emphasizes \nthe importance of providing structures for thinking about the user's problems that are \ndivorced from the structure and terminology of design.
Author: Paul Booth
Language: English
Subfield: Human-Computer Interaction
Field: Computer Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1515309742
