A Comparative Phylogenetic Approach to Austronesian Cultural Evolution
Year: 2007
Type: other
Abstract: Phylogenetic comparative methods were used to test hypotheses about cultural evolution in ethnolinguistic groups from the Austronesian language family of the Pacific.The case for quantitative statistical approaches to the empirical evolution of linguistic and cultural features was presented.Phylogenetic trees of 67 Austronesian languages were constructed using maximum parsimony and Bayesian Markov Chain Monte Carlo likelihood algorithms on a database of lexical items.The predominant transmission mode of 76 cultural traits was examined at the macroevolutionary level with (i) partial Mantel matrix tests and (ii) multiple regression on phylogenetic and geographic nearest neighbours.Mantel tests showed that both geographic and phylogenetic transmission was correlated with cultural diversity.Geographic distance had a greater overall partial correlation with cultural distance than did phylogenetic distance, but only phylogenetic correlations were found with kinship/social traits.Multiple regression on individual traits found that phylogenetic nearest neighbours predicted more cultural traits, especially those involving the inheritance of resources.Ancestral states of kinship traits were reconstructed using a Bayesian comparative method on a sample of 1000 phylogenies.The root of the tree was reconstructed as having matrilocal post-marital residence and a bilateral, flexible descent system.Proto Oceanic was reconstructed as unilocal and unilineal, and an hypothesis of matriliny and matrilocality could not be rejected.Murdock's main-sequence theory of the co-evolution of post-marital residence and descent systems was tested.The most likely model of the evolutionary pathway demonstrated that residence changed before descent.Rates of change in residence and descent traits were estimated.A co-evolutionary hypothesis of matriliny and male absence was tested.Contrary to anthropological theory, a high dependence on fishing showed no clear pattern of co-evolution with matrilineal social organisation.Population size of the language community was hypothesized to be a factor influencing lexical change.Conventional statistics showed a significant strong inverse correlation, indicating a relationship between small populations and accelerated lexical change.This correlation disappeared when comparative methods were used to control for phylogeny.Population size appeared to be evolving according to a drift model, while lexical change did not fit a neutral model of evolution.all to my supervisor, Ruth Mace, who has always made the hard tasks seem possible.I greatly appreciate her stimulating intellectual "vertical transmission", but also her constant support, especially by negotiating a way for me to return to the PhD at a time when it seemed quite impossible.Thank you, Ruth, for the high-quality investment.Without the superb efforts of Russell Gray, Simon Greenhill, and Robert Blust on the Austronesian Basic Vocabulary database, and their gracious generosity in granting me access to the language data, my research could not have progressed.Russell also provided encouragement and advice, and Simon took time to give me valuable and amusing comments on work in progress.The vastly clever Mark Pagel and Andrew Meade designed the Bayesian software used in the thesis.They gave up generous amounts of time to teach me arcane lore about Unix and probabilities, and were on call to help run analyses and fix glitches.I am extremely grateful for their help.Many thanks also to my colleagues in the CECD, "Culture Club", and the Department of Anthropology, especially Stephen Shennan and Gillian Bentley for academic guidance, and Tom Currie, Laura Fortunato, and Mhairi Gibson for friendship and unflagging encouragement.Especial thanks to Tom for
Source: Max Planck Digital Library
Author: Fiona M. Jordan
Language: English
Subfield: Cultural Studies
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1521080790
