21st Century Arms Control Challenges: Drones, Cyber Weapons, Killer Robots, and WMDs
Year: 2014
Type: article
Abstract: Dean David Wippman's remarks at the 2013 Midwest Meeting of the International Law Association focused on how we in international law struggle with the view that international law is not really law-or not really law when it comes to the use of military force.Students of legal theory will tell you, however, that defining law poses challenges in all areas of law.Understanding what counts as law is no simple task.Still, the question of whether international law is really law may be more important, especially when it comes to the use of force, because the stakes are so high.Indeed, the stakes are probably higher than with respect to any other body of rules.Compare, for example, the city of Chicago where the law against murder is frequently violated.In 2012, 500 people were murdered in Chicago; 1 few of the perpetrators will ever be identified, let alone prosecuted.When the rules on the use of force are violated, it is not hundreds that will die but hundreds of thousands.We typically know who is ultimately responsible for the resort to unlawful war and the resulting loss of life and destruction, but rarely are such persons prosecuted.In both contexts-domestic law against murder and international law against war-we must do better.I choose to work in the area of law against war and accept the challenge of persuading others as to why the law of the United Nations Charter binds the United States and all states, and why it matters that the United States and all states comply with this law.The task is challenging for a number of reasons, including the apparent decline in general knowledge respecting international law in the United States and the popularity of resort to military force.During 2013, however, we could see several indications that Americans were thinking differently about war."War fatigue" has become a common phrase.The poor results and unintended consequences of major wars involving the United States Robert and Marion Short Professor of Law and Research Professor of International Dispute Resolution
Author: Mary Ellen O’Connell
Institution: University of Notre Dame
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1529550972
