Work

Novelty conduits and forms of network ties: to bond or to bridge?

Year: 2013
Type: other
Abstract: There is ample, cross-disciplinary evidence suggesting that network ties are key to promoting\nnovelty. However, the network paradigm in organization and management theory offers\nconflicting views on what types of interorganizational ties are most valuable for organizations\nthat are pursuing novel outcomes. Drawing on the contingent view of social capital, this study\ndisentangles the contribution of ‘bonding’ and ‘bridging’ network ties in the context of two\ncritical conduits of novelty: new ventures and technological change. Empirical findings from a\nmeta-analysis of 351 effect sizes nested in 67 independent samples reveals a consistent pattern of\nnetwork ties‒performance variations. Focusing on a two-by-two matrix that encompasses distinct\nconduits of novelty—new ventures and technological change—and different levels of pressures\nfor novel outcomes—low vs. high expectation—we found two ideal profiles of network\nties‒context. Bridging ties are the best fit for the population of new ventures that have low\npressure related to technological change. By contrast, bonding ties are more valuable for\nestablished firms for which technological change requires competition for competitive advantage.\nMoreover, we uncovered a pair of suboptimal equifinal designs: bonding and bridging ties are\nequally beneficial for the performance of new ventures that face technology-intensive\nenvironments. Surprisingly, network ties are not significantly associated with performance of\nestablished firms in less technology-intensive environments, which are typically characterized by\nlower pressure for novel outcomes.
Authors: Salvatore Di Simone, Paolo Ferri, Maria Lusiani
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1533503899
Cites: 202
Cited by:
Related to: 10