Year: 2010
Type: dissertation
Abstract: In this dissertation I explore nanotechnology’s foreseen implications for the global South by asking: \nto what extent does nanotechnology offer hope for a more equitable world? Overall, I find that \nnanotechnology presently offers little hope, based on its failure to demonstrate a reflexive response \nto the legitimate requirements of equitable development. \nMy original contribution to knowledge is in placing nanotechnology’s emergence within a broad \nhistorical and contemporary global context whilst developing and testing an interpretive framework \nthrough which to assess relevant claims. Furthermore, I establish greater clarity about the nature of \nglobal engagement with nanotechnology research and development and explore a range of \nperspectives, from within both the South and North, regarding nanotechnology’s foreseen \nimplications for global inequity. \nThrough a review of the secondary literature I identify four key themes around which to question \nnanotechnology’s implications for a more equitable world, namely: understandings, innovative \ncapacity, technological appropriateness and approaches to technological governance. To consider \nnanotechnology in relation to these themes, I use an exploratory mixed methods approach, \nconsisting of two sequential phases. In order to establish the ‘state of play’, I first assess \nquantitative data surrounding national engagement, research participation and nanotechnology \npatenting. To explore matters more deeply, in the second, largely qualitative phase, I analyse the \nperspectives of 31 Thai and Australian ‘key informants’, supported by surveys of 24 Thai \nnanotechnology practitioners. \nThrough my research I find that there is agreement about nanotechnology’s common characteristics \nbut that, simultaneously, there are substantially different ways in which it is conceptualised. The \nresult is a large variation in opinion surrounding various issues such as the expected entry costs and \ninfrastructural requirements of nanotechnology research and development. Whilst there is evidence \nof widespread engagement and feasible entry points for some Southern countries into the budding \nfields of research and development, innovative capacity is shown to be increasingly centralised and \ndisengaged from ‘the local’, although the emerging gaps are as much South-South as North-South. \nIn terms of appropriateness, nanotechnologies are seen as offering numerous technical advantages, \nbut any associated benefits are set against numerous imponderables relating to risks and \nimplications, as well as economic imperatives that can mean nanotechnologies are oriented away \nfrom Southern needs. In terms of governance, Southern approaches are found to largely focus on \nsupporting innovation and managing risk at the expense of meaningful public engagement. \nOverall, an increasing concentration of capacity and influence, simplistic hype that obfuscates key \ncriteria of appropriateness and a largely ‘managed’ process of public engagement with \npredetermined desirable outcomes suggest that nanotechnology is likely to maintain and possibly \namplify the inequities stemming from existing forms of technological innovation, such as \nbiotechnology. Furthermore, debates surrounding nanotechnology and development remain so \npolarised that mainstream reflexive engagement seems unlikely. \nHowever, whilst nanotechnology presently offers little hope for a more equitable world, I conclude \nthat there is interesting new ground to explore at ‘the edge’, such as through ‘open source \nnanotechnology’ and other equity-driven practices. I argue that such boundary areas may allow \nnanotechnology to embody a process of ‘reflexive pluralisation’, leading to a more equitable world \nby revealing paths for innovation that are autonomous yet responsive to external change and \nopportunities for mutually beneficial cooperation - de-linked from national economic growth yet \nmeaningful to people’s lives. The field could then, as Schumacher proposed in 1973, blossom ‘a \nnew orientation of science and technology towards the organic, the gentle, the non-violent, the \nelegant and the beautiful’.
Author: DC Maclurcan
Institution: University of Technology Sydney
Language: English
Subfield: General Materials Science
Field: Materials Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
SDG: Reduced inequalities
Open Access status: green
Funders: National Science Foundation, United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, Royal Academy of Engineering, University of Oxford, Charles Sturt University, University of Toronto, National Science and Technology Development Agency, National Nanotechnology Center, National Metal and Materials Technology Center, National Center for Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology, National Electronics and Computer Technology Center
OpenAlex ID: W1543313791
