Work

Plasticity, life history and inclusive fitness: an evolutionary demography perspective on individual variation in fertility and fertility preferences in contemporary Britain

Year: 2012
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis consists of three papers that explore variation in individual fertility and fertility \npreference. The setting for all three papers is the contemporary UK, though the conclusions \nhave utility for a general understanding of human fertility. All three papers are motivated \nby theories arising from evolutionary biology, principally inclusive fitness theory and life \nhistory theory. \nThe first two papers investigate actualised fertility and whether patterns of fertility in \ncontemporary Britain are consistent with inclusive fitness theory. Both papers conduct \nsecondary data analysis of the British Household Panel Study. Inclusive fitness theory \npredicts that because relatives share genes an individual may obtain fitness benefits by \nincreasing the reproduction of a relative. Results support this hypothesis showing that for \ncontemporary British women kin having more opportunities to influence reproductive \ndecision-making is associated with pro-fitness fertility outcomes. In the first paper I find \nkin accelerate the transition to first birth, and the second paper shows kin also accelerate \nthe transition to second birth. \nThe final paper tests a different hypothesis derived from evolutionary theory. Life history \ntheory predicts that reproductive strategy should have ‘plasticity’ and be liable to alter as \nperceived environmental risk changes. This paper uses primary data collected from \nUniversity students using an internet experiment and finds that priming respondents using \npreceding questions on mortality does alter reported fertility preferences, though the effects \ndepend upon the priming, fertility preference measure and the sex of the respondent. The \npaper also has methodological relevance as it demonstrates the potential for ‘context \neffects’ from preceding questions to influence the reporting of fertility preferences. \nAll three papers present evidence that the incorporation of theories from evolutionary \nbiology have utility in the understanding of contemporary fertility patterns and processes.
Author: Paul Mathews
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1547503703
Cites: 307
Cited by: 3
Related to: 9