Work

Teasing apart disadvantage from disorder The case of poor language

Year: 2013
Type: book-chapter
Abstract: Teasing apart disadvantage from disorder: The case of poor languagePenny Roy and Shula Chiat When children's development is out-of-step with expectations, for example, if they lack social or language skills appropriate for their age, this may reflect factors internal to the child, external factors, or, indeed, a combination of these.While the genetic basis for autism and ADHD is clear (see Newbury, chapter 2, this volume) approximately half the children that Rutter and colleagues studied who were adopted from Romanian orphanages following 6 months or more of institutional care had autistic-like features, cognitive delay, inattention/hyperactivity, and disinhibited attachment (Kreppner et al., 2007).This is a much higher proportion than would be expected to demonstrate these traits in the general population who have not suffered such horrific early deprivation.Similar observations can be made about language impairment: while genetic sources for developmental language deficits have been demonstrated (see again Newbury chapter 2), as many as 50% of children from socially disadvantaged backgrounds do not have language skills appropriate to their age (Locke, Ginsborg, & Peers, 2002).Again, this greatly exceeds expected rates of impairment arising from child-internal factors.We would obviously expect some of those Romanian orphans to have had autism or ADHD, and some children with low SES to have language impairment; we might also expect that effects of external factors will be intertwined with internal factors (see Thomas, chapter 4, this volume).But if children have impaired language skills, does it matter what lies behind these?Teasing apart the contribution of external and internal factors, we argue, is important if we are to understand the developmental pathways that lead to poorer-than-expected performance, and if we are to offer appropriate intervention.Addressing the distinction between poor language due to disadvantage and intrinsic language disorder is therefore important in theory and practice.In this chapter, we review studies of speech and language in preschool children and primary school aged children from low socioeconomic backgrounds.We will draw on evidence from the UK, US and our own studies of preschoolers.We begin by considering what factors comprise SES classifications, discuss the non-linear relationship between language performance and SES, and evaluate the extent to which SES-related differences are due to differences in care-giving.This is followed by a more detailed discussion of what is meant by language impairment and the nature of SES-related poor language performance, including the knotty issue of whether and how, theoretically and empirically, we can tease apart language delay due to 'disadvantage' as opposed to 'disorder', and the kind of measures that are required to do this.We highlight social and cultural biases of standard measures used to assess children's language, and make a case for measures proposed to be less affected by differences in environment and experience, drawing on evidence from others' studies.We then present unexpected findings from our own studies using these measures, and discuss the implications for language delay in children from low SES backgrounds, including the role of attention, executive function, and self-regulation.The conclusions we draw have implications for the types of intervention needed to promote language skills in children in socially disadvantaged communities. Classification of SES'Socioeconomic disadvantage' and 'low SES' are relative, not absolute, terms that vary according to which reference factors and cut-offs are adopted.Classifications are derived from single or combined measures (Hollingshead, 1975) of factors thought to relate to families' 'living conditions' including occupational, educational and income levels of main carers (see Hernandez & Blazer, 2006, Chapter 2 for full discussion of these social environmental variables and their relation to health).Primary and secondary caregivers, either singly or combined, may be targeted, and information gained either directly or through self-completed questionnaires.SES levels may refer to individual factors (e.g.occupational status (Hart & Risley, 1995) or parental education level (Fenson et al., 2000)).Separate SES measures are significantly interrelated (Hart & Risley, 1995;Roy & Chiat, submitted).Broader classifications of SES are often adopted (e.g.low, middle and high) based on either composite measures or single factors.Although income has been found to be more predictive of cognitive development and vocabulary (Duncan, Brooks-Gunn, & Klebanov, 1994;Marulis & Neuman, 2010), education level has probably been more widely used in research on early language acquisition.Parents are often more willing to provide education and occupation data than income data (Noble, McCandliss, & Farah, 2007).Measures may extend beyond individual families to the wider community such measures have been adopted in studies of SES and early language development (e.g.free school meals (Locke et al., 2002); ACORN (A Classification of Residential Neighbourhood, Dodd et al., 2003); the Index of Multiple Deprivation (Roy, Chiat, & Dodd, 2010).Whatever measures are adopted, SES indices influence outcomes through the quality of the physical and psychological environments that children experience.Significant factors associated with SES and poverty in the pre-, peri-and post-natal periods include, for example, exposure to toxins and psychological stress, nutritional levels, parenting styles, cognitive stimulation and educational experiences.Differences in reported language outcomes across studies are likely to be a function of the nature and heterogeneity of the sample, the range in SES variables and the stringency of cut-offs for defining low SES groups (Arriaga et al., 1998).There is increasing evidence that the relation between SES and language outcomes is nonlinear: poorest outcomes are disproportionately associated with the most socially and
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1551437804
FWCI: 14.59
Cites: 76
Cited by: 47
Related to: 9