Work

Can hunting? : an analysis of recent changes in the legal framework governing the management of large predators in South Africa.

Year: 2008
Type: dissertation
Abstract: New regulations have been published under the National Environmental Management: Biodiversity \nAct ('the Biodiversity Act') that regulate activities regarded as 'restricted activities' by that Act \ninvolving listed species of flora and fauna. The regulations include several provisions relating \nspecifically to five species of large predator (lions are a notable exception) and to black and white \nrhinoceros and represent the end of a lengthy law reform process. The regulations came into force \non 1 February 2008. \nSouth Africa is a signatory to several international instruments concerned with the protection of \nbiodiversity including the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species ('CITES'), the \nUnited Nations Convention on Biological Diversity and the SADC Protocol on Wildlife \nConservation and Law Enforcement in the Southern African Development Community. The \nBiodiversity Act is the key national law concerned with management of large predators from a \nconservation and biodiversity protection point of view. Several Acts administered by the \nDepartment of Agriculture, such as the Animals Protection Act and the Performing Animals \nProtection Act, provide for the welfare of animals in captivity. However, the management of wild \npredators has up to now been regulated at provincial level by a series of outdated nature \nconservation ordinances that are inconsistent with one another and with the provisions of CITES. \nIt is clear from the Game Theft Act, from national policy instruments such as the National \nBiodiversity Strategy and Action Plan and from the draft Game Farming Policy that hunting and \ngame farming are seen as important contributors to the South African economy with the potential to \naddress rural poverty and create employment. Hunting is itself a multimillion rand industry in \nSouth Africa and a substantial part of that industry is trophy hunting. Large predators in South Africa are most affected by trophy hunting practices, but other animals and other predators are also \naffected. Large predators are also the subject ofboth national and international trade. In recent years \ncaptive breeding of large predators has increased dramatically in order to supply the trophy hunting \nindustry. During the late 1990s concerns began to be raised in the press regarding so-called 'canned \nhunting' practices and the law reform process mentioned in the first paragraph was partially a result \nofthis focus on canned hunting. \nThe new regulations provide, among other things, for greater control of the wildlife industry and for \nthe setting ofhunting off-take limits, but they have several weaknesses. On the most basic level, the \nregulations contain drafting errors, are overly complex and may conflict with existing provincial \nlegislation. They are likely to impose a greater administrative burden on provincial authorities \nalready struggling to implement the existing provincial legislation. It is submitted that the \nprovisions relating to animal welfare (for example, those dealing with prohibited methods of \nhunting) should have been enacted elsewhere. The provisions relating to self-regulation of the \nhunting industry and black economic empowerment are ineffectual as currently drafted. \nMost importantly, the new regulations do not represent a significant departure from the utilitarian \napproach to wild animals that has characterised South African law since its earliest days. In this \nsense, the regulations conform to the current policy of 'making conservation pay'.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1552004157
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10