Year: 2009
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: The purpose of the research study was to examine Leadership Orientation Style and Use of Power by New Jersey male superintendents in order to better understand the contemporary profile, leadership style, and use of power of the New Jersey male superintendent.A secondary purpose of the study was to compare the findings with those of a recent New Jersey study of female superintendents (Edmunds, 2007).Data was collected using the Leadership Orientation Style (Self-reporting) Survey developed by Bolman and Deal (1990).The survey is aligned with their Four Frame Model of Leadership which views leadership through the lens of four different perspectives, the structural, human resource, political, and symbolic frames.The findings were also examined in the context of the Three Dimensional Model of Power (Fowler, 2004) developed from prevailing theory in the study of power.Interviews were conducted with eleven sitting New Jersey male superintendents to give "voice" to the survey data.Approximately 35.8% (n = 154) of the 430 surveys were returned (n = 154).Overall, the findings of the study suggested that New Jersey males exercised a multi-dimensional leadership style and associated closely with the behaviors of all four frames.The predominant frame was the human resource frame, followed closely by the structural, symbolic, and political frames.Overriding themes were identified as accountability, communication, and power.The data suggested males as comfortable with the construct of power, exercising transactional leadership tendencies.When compared to the findings of the female study, the researcher concluded that males and females had differing views on power, and that females, who reported transformational leadership tendencies, were more uncomfortable with exercise of power than were males.Both males and females identified their highest frame association with the human resource frame and lowest association with the political frame.
Author: Sandra DeLuca
Institution: Seton Hall University
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1556612934
