Work

On the relation between audiences and publics

Year: 2005
Type: book-chapter
Abstract: Audience versus publicThe analysis of 'audience' and 'public' draws on distinctive bodies of theory, prioritising different issues.But they do not refer to wholly separate realities.In a thoroughly mediated world, audiences and publics, along with communities, nations, markets and crowds, are composed of the same people.This apparently On the relation between audiences and publics 17banal observation is significant when we observe that it is commonplace to define audiences in opposition to the public.In both popular and elite discourses, audiences are denigrated as trivial, passive, individualised, while publics are valued as active, critically engaged and politically significant.Bearing in mind that the audience is generally ascribed to the private domain, consider these common associations of public versus private, each of which valorises public over private: rational versus emotional, disinterested versus biased, participatory versus withdrawn, shared versus individualised, visible versus hidden.Adherents of this oppositional view, often from a political science or political communication approach, tend to ascribe a clear meaning to the public in terms of political citizenship and then ask how the media support or -more commonly -undermine public understanding and public participation.If objective information, informed consent, independent investigation are all prerequisites for a flourishing democracy, the questions for research are clear.And the answers, all too often, tend to suggest that the effect of media on their audience is seen to reposition what was or might be or should be, a public (knowing, thinking, influential) as a mere crowd (watching, sharing and emoting) or mass of consumers (driven by tastes, preferences and motivations) (Gandy, 2002).This suspicion of the media has a long history that is strongly if implicitly encoded in our present-day tendency not only to oppose mediated communication with face-to-face communication, judging the former as inferior by comparison, but also in the ways that we map onto this opposition our cultural norms of reliability, authenticity, equality, trust, accountability -all of which are associated with face-to-face communication and all of which are routinely questioned in relation to the media.Hence, popular and academic discourses worry -undoubtedly often with good reason -about the extent to which 'media culture generally, with its emphasis on consumption and entertainment, has undercut the kind of public culture needed for a healthy democracy' (Dahlgren, 2003, p.151).Or, to put these worries into the much-used language of moral panics, many are concerned about 'citizens attenuated into measurable audiences and consumers; politics commodified into beauty pageant cum talent show; journalists transmogrified into masters of ceremony, celebrity judges and measurers of the public will' (Barnhurst, 1998, p. 203).The outcome, so the argument goes, is that the media undermine the public sphere (Habermas, 1969/89), transform politics into political marketing (Scammell, 2001), bias the news agenda according to commercial imperatives (McChesney, 2000) and distract citizens from civic engagement (Putnam, 2000).On this view, then, the last thing research should be doing is rethinking those processes of attenuation in potentially more positive terms through studying such denigrated formats as daytime talk shows or reality television, particularly when there remains so much to do to improve the reception of prime-time news or to defend resources for the documentary. On the relation between audiences and publics 19
Language: English
Subfield: Communication
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1556780311
FWCI: 13.95
Cites: 19
Cited by: 126
Related to: 10