Assessment for learning : a case study in mathematics education
Year: 2012
Type: dissertation
Study design: Clinical Trial
Abstract: The aim of this study was to introduce a formative-assessment \npractice in a mathematics classroom, by implementing the five \nstrategies of the formative-assessment framework proposed by \nWiliam and Thompson (2007), in order to investigate: (a) if this \nchange in assessment practices had a positive influence on students’ \nmathematical learning and, if this was the case, (b) which these \nchanges were, and (c) how the teacher and students perceived these \nchanges in relation to the new teaching-learning environment. \nThe study was conducted in a mathematics classroom during the \nstudents’ first year in upper-secondary school. A quasiexperimental \ndesign was chosen for the study, involving pre- and \npost-tests, as well as an intervention group and control group. The \nintervention was characterized by: 1) making goals and criteria explicit \nby a systematic use of a scoring rubric; 2) making students’ \nlearning visible by a use of problem-solving tasks and working in \nsmall groups; 3) providing students with nuanced information \nabout their performance, including ways to move forward in their \nlearning; 4) activating students as resources for each other through \npeer-assessment and peer-feedback activities; and 5) creating a forum \nfor communication about assessment, involving both the students \nand the teacher. \nThe findings indicate an improvement in problem-solving performance \nfor the students in the intervention group, for instance \nregarding how well they are able to interpret a problem and use \nappropriate mathematical methods to solve it. The students also \nshow improvements in how to reason about mathematical solu12 \ntions, how to present a solution in a clear and accessible manner, \nand how to appropriately use mathematical symbols, terminology, \nand conventions. The findings also indicate a change in students’ \nmathematical-related beliefs during the intervention, towards beliefs \nmore productive for supporting learning in mathematics. The \nchanges in students’ beliefs include mathematical understanding, \nmathematical work, and the usefulness of mathematical \nknowledge. During interviews, the students expressed how they \nperceived the new teaching-learning environment. Students’ responses \nindicate that they recognized and appreciated the different \ncomponents of the formative-assessment practice as resources for \ntheir learning. Responses from both students and the teacher also \nindicate that the components of the formative-assessment practice \nwere linked in complex ways, often supporting and reinforcing \neach other. Furthermore, most components had other effects as \nwell, besides supporting the formative strategies they were intended \nto. \nThe findings from this study deepens our understanding of how \nthe components of a formative-assessment practice may influence \nstudents and their learning in mathematics, but also how these \ncomponents co-exist in an authentic classroom situation and influence \neach other.
Author: Andreia Balan
Institution: Malmö University
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: formative assessment, mathematics education, upper secondary school, problem solving, rubrics, peer assessment, peer feedback, mathematical reasoning, teaching and learning environment, teacher perceptions, student perceptions, small group work, feedback to students, assessment for learning, student self-efficacy, student self-confidence in mathematics
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1557948063
