Work

Effects of Alternative Types of Counsel on Criminal Procedure Treatment

Year: 1973
Type: article
Abstract: The purpose of this article is to present some findings with regard to how defendants having certain types of counsel differ in their criminal procedure treatment from defendants who have other types of counsel.The comparisons studied are: (1) counsel versus no counsel; (2) hired counsel versus provided counsel; (3) public defender versus assigned counsel; and (4) early-obtained counsel versus late-obtained counsel.The findings in this article are based on previous data gathered by Lee Silverstein for the American Bar Foundation. 1 That data covered 11,258 felony cases for the year 1962, taken from a sample of 194 counties located in all fifty states.In order to control for the type of crime committed,' we will only be concerned in this analysis with the 1,101 state grand larceny cases examined in the Silverstein study.'Various questions may be raised as to the value of re-examining the Silverstein data: ( 1) Doesn't the Silverstein study itself provide ample treatment of the subject?; (2) If not, haven't other studies effectively covered the area?; (3) What is the current value of findings based on 1962 data--especially in light of Gideon v. Wainwright?' Because of
Institution: Indiana University
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1567446785
FWCI: 24.61
Cites:
Cited by: 29
Related to: 8