Work

An overview and critique of the '10,000 hours rule' and 'theory of deliberate practice'

Year: 2012
Type: book
Abstract: Who is an expert? What is expertise?Before we consider Ericsson and colleagues' views on the conditions and factors which enable expertise to develop it is important to consider the questions -'who is an expert?', and 'what is expertise?' -because, as will become clear, the definitions adopted have a significant bearing on the way in which the phenomenon is described, and the recommendations for action.Historically, there have been different notions about who is an expert, what expertise is, and how expertise is developed.One commonly held view is that an expert is "someone widely recognised as a reliable source of knowledge, technique or skill, whose judgement is accorded authority and status by the public or his or her peers" (Wikipedia, 2005).Expertise then refers to the characteristics, skills, and knowledge that distinguish experts from novices and less experienced people according to general and peer assessment.Another common perception is that talent is hereditary ('innate', 'natural', 'born') which derives, it is frequently argued, from Francis Galton's 1896 study 'Hereditary Genius' (Galton, 1896/1979) -but may also be a common sense everyday perception of, for example, parents and coaches.Thus, when pundits and supporters talk about Wayne Rooney, for example, they suggest 'he's got natural talent', that is, an hereditary gift he was born with.Another commonly held perception is that experts have prolonged or intense experience in their domain through practice and education. Question BoxThink about the players you have worked with.How do you assess whether a player is high performing/expert?What markers do you use?Which factors are most important in determining playing success -hereditary factors such as 'natural ability', or environmental factors such as 'training and working hard', 'good coaching' and 'supportive parents'?These common views on expertise, however, have been challenged by Ericsson and colleagues. When high profile members of a domain are asked to identify their 'expert peers', for example, the 'coaches' coach of the year', the 'experts' identified often do not perform well when asked to work on specific tasks compared with novices  There is no evidence, it is argued, of hereditary characteristics as a predictor of future expertise.For example, there is no correlation between IQ and expert performance in fields such as chess, music, sports, and medicine.The exception is height and body size which can be significant in some sports  Furthermore, extensive professional experience, it is argued, is not a guarantee of expert performance
Author: Julian North
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1572256514
FWCI:
Cites: 64
Cited by: 10
Related to: 10