Year: 2009
Type: article
Abstract: I INTRODUCTION The world has clearly registered its opinion about desirability and effectiveness of truth commissions. From South Korea to Peru, truth commissions (and functionally equivalent institutions) have been established as a means of addressing historical injustices. (1) Indeed, out of limited list of mechanisms for dealing with historical injustices and preparing a pathway toward a more secure and democratic future, truth commissions stand out as a very common choice of states haunted by their own histories. (2) But are truth commissions effective? Of course, first part of answer to this question requires an answer to an earlier query: Effective at what? Can a truth commission create a democratic political system? Probably not. Can it erase a history of intense political conflict, bringing all sides together in a spirit of mutual respect and cooperation? Surely not. But, to lower our expectations, can a truth commission contribute to a collective memory for a society, providing at least some common understanding of a country's conflictual past, including some appreciation of motives of the enemy? Can a truth commission contribute to development of a rule-of-law culture that respects human rights and thereby raises costs of future efforts to violate human rights of citizenry? Can a truth commission advance political tolerance, a central component of a democratic political culture and a necessary ingredient for coexistence? The answers to these questions, while still subject to considerable disagreement and debate, are most likely that, under at least some conditions and to at least a limited degree, truth commissions can indeed contribute to societal transformation. Indeed, rigorous empirical evidence on effectiveness of South African truth and reconciliation process supports this conclusion. (3) It appears that South African process generated a truth about past that is fairly widely accepted. It appears as well that those who buy into that truth tend to be more reconciled with country's past, their fellow South Africans, and political institutions of country's new dispensation. And it seems that this reconciliation has been crucial in buying South African transition some breathing space during which nascent democratic institutions and processes have been established and nurtured. The truth and reconciliation process in South Africa did not produce a secure, consolidated, democratic political system (in terms of either culture or institutions). But available evidence suggests that some portion of South African miracle can reasonably be attributed to success of Commission's efforts to find truth and create reconciliation. (4) At same time, however, truth commissions often fail, even when expectations are minimal. Many commissions appear to have had little, if any, impact on societal transformations. Indeed, some view commissions as product of social change rather than cause of it. (5) Although it is certainly too soon to assess many of ongoing efforts at truth and reconciliation throughout world today, it would not be terribly surprising to find that truth commissions more often fail than succeed. What, then, contributes to success at creating truth and stimulating reconciliation? Few would argue with assertion that South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) is among most successful in world; indeed, TRC is widely emulated by societies seeking some sort of transition from atrocities in past to more-peaceful and democratic politics in future. (6) But what key elements of South African process contributed to its success? Are these factors generalizable to other polities, cultures, and circumstances? It is important to determine what lessons can be learned from South African experience, and to provide some desiderata for those who would use truth as a mean of enhancing reconciliation and democratic change. …
Source: Law and Contemporary Problems
Author: James L. Gibson
Language: English
Topic: War, Law, and Justice
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: truth commissions, Truth and Reconciliation Commission, legitimacy theory, transitional justice, historical injustice, collective memory, political tolerance, reconciliation, rule of law, human rights, democratic transition, societal transformation, post-conflict societies, political institutions
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1581489056
