The Globalization of a Social Disease: Populist Homophobia and the Crisis of the Nation-State
Year: 2010
Type: preprint
Abstract: The adoption of laws across the US prohibiting legal recognition of same sex relationships since 2000 might be notorious, but this movement is not unique. In the same period, Senegalese authorities have arrested AIDS activists on charges of sexual impropriety, their Polish counterparts banned gay pride, and Iranian courts punished homosexuality with hanging. After flirting with its own ban on same sex marriage, Uganda has considered a criminalization statute that mandates execution in some cases and even punishes those who advocate for or know of LGBT advocates. Globally, criminal law and rhetoric transformed homosexuality from a “love that dare not speak” to a target for the mobilization of state power, even before LGBT movements have emerged, drawing increasing concern from global human rights, global LGBT rights activists, and HIV/AIDS activists. Against the suggestion of increasing tolerance in the West confronting forms of intolerance read as traditional, religious, or regressive elsewhere, this paper examines the rising torrent of a populist homophobia within the context of the neoliberal crisis and the weakening of the state. Contemporary affirmations of the criminalization of homosexuality and anti-LGBT rhetoric reflect anxieties related to internal and external challenges to a weakened state, where such anxieties echo shared aspirations to power within the context of global and local crises. With origins in a 19th Century British imperial system that exported criminal laws related to homosexuality and the embrace of such laws after decolonization in the Francophonie, where French law never criminalized sexual conduct, the contemporary homophobic impulse has been considered as a reaction to the global expansion of an LGBT movement. This paper considers state homophobia has a chosen strategy of governance, especially in contexts where LGBT organizing has not emerged or is primarily privatized and weak to an extent that demands on the state are not feasible, and not as a response to the demands of traditionalists or the transformation of private prejudice into policy. Examples include the collapse of the state and foreign occupation in Bosnia and Iraq, where Muslim men were forced into ritualized same sex sexual behavior; international demands for economic reform in Poland and Malaysia produced a rejection of homosexuality through a complicated dance with the West; and the forces of faith worked through elaborate transnational networks linking the US and Uganda to deploy homophobia where a local gay rights movement has only emerged i response to state instigations. These strategies reflect the imposition of contestations to further the interests of state actors, their allies and proxies that, while cultural and social, reflect the practice of building state and nation.
Source: SSRN Electronic Journal
Author: Marta Bosia
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1587652026
