Year: 2006
Type: article
Abstract: T]he line between discriminatory purpose and discriminatory impact is not nearly as bright, and perhaps not quite as critical, as the reader of the Court's opinion might assume.I In this single sentence, Justice John Paul Stevens suggests all of the problems with the uneasy distinction between disparate impact and discriminatory purpose under the Constitution and the civil rights laws.Both theories of liability rely upon the same evidence.Yet each theory purports to establish unique standards of liability, disparate impact more favorably for plaintiffs and discriminatory purpose more favorably for defendants.This observation, offered almost in passing by Justice Stevens, in fact raises profound issues about the goals and methods of civil rights law-what it seeks to achieve and how it goes about achieving it.The uncertain fault line between disparate impact and discriminatory purpose cuts through almost all the major issues in this field, with implications for subjects as different as affirmative action, racist and sexist stereotyping, and the distinctive features of age discrimination, an issue most recently addressed by Justice Stevens's opinion in Smith v. City of Jackson. 2 The distinction between disparate impact and discriminatory intent raises so many issues because it marks the boundary between consensus and controversy over the concept of equality in civil rights law.This is the point at which litigation, argument, and judicial decisions depart from widely shared understandings about what laws against discrimination prohibit and turn to intensely fought disputes over what those laws seek to achieve.Adapting terminology from the philosophical literature, 3 at this point the overlapping consensus on discrimination gives way to the essentially contested concept of equality.The theory of disparate impact
Source: Fordham law review
Author: George Rutherglen
Institution: Fordham University
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1589025444
