Work

Creating a competitive education industry: Introduction

Year: 2005
Type: article
Abstract: This special issue of the Cato Journal explores the nature of a competitive education industry (CEI) by examining the key ingredients of and minimal requirements for a true education market. Most of the articles were first presented at the Cato Institute's conference on Creating a True Marketplace in Education held in Washington in September 2004. The articles are intended to serve as a starting point for an increasingly informed discussion of the CEI concept. We also want to highlight the differences between a CEI and the traditional school system governance and funding processes that prevail--and disappoint--virtually everywhere. In our article, we describe the CEI concept and the reasons for devoting more attention to studying it. Understanding the critical elements of a competitive education market is essential. Unless we know what the key ingredients are, we cannot design policies or programs that will lead to establishing such a system. In our article, we point out eight critical ingredients for a CEI and describe why each ingredient must be present for a true CEI to emerge. Australian economist Mark Harrison looks at the problems with government provision of education in general. The major problems he points to are the lack of normal market incentives, the lack of innovation, and the inability to encourage good teaching. Also, because the unsatisfactory performance of the government school system affects those from impoverished backgrounds the most, government provision of schooling has the unintended consequence of harming the poor. Harrison then describes how a market approach would solve each of these problems. John Wenders shows how U.S. public schools today operate much like the U.S. airline industry did before the 1980s, when the now-defunct Civil Aeronautics Board exercised monopoly power over most aspects of airline operations. As in the pre-CAB airline industry, the results of this regulated monopoly are waste, rent dissipation, entrenched parasitic constituencies, and organizational sclerosis, making public schools impervious to change. Consumers, faced with a monopoly, cannot escape by voting with their feet. Thus, producers eater to political pressures, not to consumers. By comparing U.S. public and private school costs, Wenders identifies the primary sources, and causes, of waste in the public system. Wenders calculates the amount of waste to be nearly $160 billion annually, about 1.58 percent of U.S. gross domestic product, or about $560 per capita for the year 2000. Myron Lieberman compares the educational research produced by the current system with research produced by some large industries driven by free enterprise. He explains how government support has politicized research, and that there are few incentives for teachers to utilize best practices. For this reason, research on more effective or efficient educational methods has had little impact on schools. Lieberman contrasts this situation with how research is utilized in competitive industries. His analysis suggests that a competitive education industry would prompt the diligent pursuit and rapid adoption of effective education practices. Charter schools, which often operate under heavy regulation and in close contact with the status quo, are generally viewed as lacking most of the needed competitive features for a CEI. Yet Lisa Snell shows that, to date, charter schools have generated the most growth in the crucial for-profit education sector and substantial growth in brand name nonprofit schools. Because charter options tend to have more political support than reforms like vouchers and tax credits, Snell argues for a course of action that involves increasing competition for charter school authorizers, abolishing caps on the number of charter schools, and legalizing for-profit charter schools in states where they are currently prohibited. Such a course can push education reform in a more market-oriented direction. …
Source: Cato Journal
Institution: Cato Institute
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1591030467
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10