Work

Fundamentalism, the First Amendment, and the Rise of the Religious Right

Year: 2010
Type: article
Abstract: The First Amendment must have been very much on Thomas Jefferson's mind on New Year's Day, 1 802. As he sat down to catch up on his correspondence, the President came across a letter dated October 7 of the previous year and signed by Nehemiah Dodge, Ephram Robb ins, and Stephen S. Nelson on behalf of a group of Baptists from Danbury, Connecticut.1 A year before that, when Jefferson was running against the incumbent President, John Adams, Jefferson's heterodoxy was very much an issue, especially among the Federalists in New England,2 who feared the loss of Congregationalism the preferred religion in Connecticut and Massachusetts.3 In response to the campaign invective directed against Jefferson, Baptists, Presbyterians, and other dissenters had rallied to his defense. The occasion of the letter from the Baptists in Danbury, Connecticut, was to express support for the President's efforts to extend religious disestablishment to the states. Our sentiments are uniformly on the side of religious liberty, the Baptists wrote, Religion is at all times and places a matter between God and individuals; that no man ought to suffer in name, person, or effects on account of his religious opinions.4 Earlier that same day, Jefferson had received an unusual entourage at the White House. While Jefferson was spending his days at Monticello, he had befriended a Baptist neighbor, John Leland, who became one of Jefferson's most fervent supporters.5 Leland moved to Cheshire, Massachusetts, in 1792 and continued his ministry among the Baptists there, many of whom had come from Rhode Island.6 Leland enthusiastically supported Jefferson's election in 1 800, rallying the town of Cheshire behind him.7 Early during Jefferson's first term, Leland sought to demonstrate that not all of New England opposed the Virginian. The Baptist preacher came up with the idea of presenting the President with a local product of domestic arts a token of the town's support and affection.8 Some of the residents of Cheshire, Massachusetts, had come from Cheshire, Connecticut, a town known for its cheese-makers. Leland directed that all of the locals in Cheshire, Massachusetts, collect the milk from their cows on a single day, July 20, 1801, prepare the curds, and bring them to the farm of Elisha Brown Jr.9 Brown's large cider press, with some modification, provided a cheese hoop, four feet in diameter and eighteen inches tall. 10 Leland specifically directed that no milk from Federalist cows be allowed, lest it should leaven the whole lump with a distasteful savour.11 As the whey was being pressed out of the hoop, Leland blessed the cheese, dedicated it to the nation's chief executive, and led the townspeople in the singing of a hymn.12 The cheese bore the Jeffersonian motto, Rebellion to tyrants is obethence to God.13 A month after the pressing, the round of cheese weighed in at 1,235 pounds.14 Additional curds had been sufficient to produce another three rounds, each weighing seventy pounds. 15 By early December, the Cheese, it was known, was placed on a sled and carried to Hudson, New York, where it was conveyed by barge first to New York City and then (accounts differ) on to Baltimore and Washington.16 Leland and a friend, Darius Brown, accompanied the cheese, either in the same conveyance or by parallel route; Leland, who had long experience an itinerant minister, preached to authences along the way.17 The December 30, 1801 edition of the National Intelligencer and Washington Advertiser recorded the arrival of the Mammoth Cheese: Yesterday the cheese, made in Massachusetts to be presented to the President, was brought to the city in a wagon drawn by six horses.18 On the morning of New Year's Day, 1802, Leland presented the cheese to the President, as a token of the esteem we bear to our chief Magistrate, along with an effusive letter of support from the people of Cheshire, Massachusetts.19 The declaration included appreciation for the Constitution and its prohibition of religious tests to prevent all hierarchy. …
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1591320836
FWCI:
Cites: 4
Cited by: 7
Related to: 10