Assessing and correcting for the effects of species misclassification during passive acoustic surveys of cetaceans
Year: 2013
Type: dissertation
Abstract: In conservation ecology, abundance estimates are an important factor from which management decisions are\nbased. Methods to estimate abundance of cetaceans from visual detections are largely developed, whereas\nparallel methods based on passive acoustic detections are still in their infancy. To estimate the abundance of\ncetacean species using acoustic detection data, it is first necessary to correctly identify the species that are\ndetected. The current automatic PAMGUARD Whistle Classifier used to automatically identify whistle\ndetection of cetacean species is modified with the objective to facilitate the use of these detections to\nestimate cetacean abundance. Given the variability of cetacean sounds within and between species,\ndeveloping an automated species classifier with a 100% correct classification probability for any species is\nunfeasible. However, through the examples of two case studies it is shown that large and high quality\ndatasets with which to develop these automatic classifiers increase the probability of creating reliable\nclassifiers with low and precise misclassification probability.\nGiven that misclassification is unavoidable, it is necessary to consider the effect of misclassified detections\non the number of observed acoustic calls detected and thus on abundance estimates, and to develop robust\nmethods to cope with these misclassifications. Through both heuristic and Bayesian approaches it is\ndemonstrated that if misclassification probabilities are known or estimated precisely, it is possible to\nestimate the true number of detected calls accurately and precisely. However, misclassification and\nuncertainty increase the variance of the estimates. If the true numbers of detections from different species\nare similar, then a small amount of misclassification between species and a small amount of uncertainty in\nthe probabilities of misclassification does not have a detrimental effect on the overall variance and bias of\nthe estimate. However, if there is a difference in the encounter rate between species calls associated with a\nlarge amount of uncertainty in the probabilities of misclassification, then the variance of the estimates\nbecomes larger and the bias increases; this in return increases the variance and the bias of the final\nabundance estimate. This study despite not bringing perfect results highlights for the first time the\nimportance of dealing with the problem of species misclassification for cetacean if acoustic detections are to\nbe used to estimate abundance of cetaceans.
Author: Marjolaine Caillat
Institution: University of St Andrews
Language: English
Subfield: Ecology
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1594330921
