Year: 1991
Type: article
Abstract: IOGENES OF BABYLON, fifth scholarch of the Stoa and flour- ishing in the first half of the second century B.C. , has not been accorded the attention his philosophical and historical importance merits. 1 He receives only passing notice in the standard histories of Stoicism, despite abundant evidence that he effected a far-reaching revision of Stoic doctrine in such fields as linguistics,2 music education,3 philosophical psycho 1ogy,4 rhetoric,5 ethics,6 and political philosophy.7 Accidents of 1 There is no adequate modern study of Diogenes and his work: for collections of evidence see C. F. Thiery's Dissertatio de Diogene Babylonio (diss.Louvain 1830), esp.90-96 for evidence concerning his catalogue of writings; F. Susemihl, Geschichte der griechischen Litteratur (Leipzig 1891) 82ff; H. von Armin, RE 5 (1903) 773-76. 2 Diogenes' handbooks On Voice and On the Dialectical Art are the basis for the account of the Stoic theory of dialectic and language in D.L. 7.55-58, 71 (=SVF III 17-26, pp.212-15); a long quotation on q>(J)vTj from his On the Governing Part of the Soul is discussed by Galen, De plac.2.128.32-132.16De Lacy.For Diogenes' influence on later Stoic linguistics sec M. Frede, "The Origins of Traditional Grammar," in R. E. Butts and].IIintikka, edd., Historical and Philosophical Dimensions of Logic, Methodology and Philosophy of Science (Dordrecht 1977) 51-79 (=Essays in Ancient Philosophy [Minneapolis 1987] 338-59); W. Ax, Laut, Stimme und Sprache: Studien zu drei Grundbegriffen der antiken Sprachtheorie (=l!ypomnemata 84 [Gottingen 1986]), who argues that Diogenes reformulated Chrysippus' position in part to take account of Aristotle; and D. M. Schenkeveld, "The Stoic 't£XVT} m:p1.<p(J)vilc;." and "Developments in the Study of Ancient Linguistics," Mnemosyne SER. 4 43 (1990) 86-108, 298-306.3 Diogenes' On Music: texts in D. Dclattre, "Philodeme, De la musique: livre IV, colonnes 40* a 109*," CronErcol 19 (1989) 49-143; see also R. Janko, "A First Join between P.H erc.411 + 1583 [Philodemus, On Music IVJ: Diogencs of Babylon on Natural Affinity and Music," CronErcol22 (1992) 123-30, for the first Stoic account of how music education is conducive in the training of the passions to the acquisition of virtue.4 Diogenes clearly anticipated the modifications in Stoic psychology often traced to Panaetius or Posidollius by divid ing the soul into separate parts along Platonic lines (cf De mus.IV cols.56*,57*.40-41,69*.3,74*), a move S We hope in a future paper to reconstruct the philosophical motivation of early Stoic rhetorical theory with special attention to Diogenes' innovations.See also D. Sohlberg, "Aelius Aristides und Diogenes von Babylon.Zur Geschichte des rednerischen Ideals," M usHelv 29 (1972) 177-200, 256-77.6 Particularly noteworthy are his revision of earlier Stoic doctrine on the 'tEAo'; (Arius Didymus ap.Stob.Eclog.22.76.9fWachsmuth; D.L. 7.88; Clem.AI.Strom.2.21), and his famous debate (ap.Cic.Off 3.49-55; cf 89-92) with Antipater over the nature and justification of private property: see most recently J. Annas, "Cicero on Stoic Moral Philosophy and Private Property," in M. Griffin and J. Barnes, edd., Philosophia Togata (Oxford 1989) 151-73.Both underscore Diogenes' central concern to provide practical moral guidance in contemporary society.7 For an attempt to show that Diogenes was responsible for important changes in the scope of Stoic political philosophy see P. A. Vander Waerdt, "Politics and Philosophy in Stoicism," Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 9(1991) 185-211 at205-10.8 Diogenes' traditional dates are ca 240-150, the dramatic date of Cicero's De Senectute, where he appears (7.23) in a list of notables who remained productive until an advanced old age: Lucian, Macr.20, says he lived to the age of eighty-eight.But Cicero, who mentions there Diogenes' recent visit to Rome in 155, does not actually say that Diogenes was dead by this time, and T. Dorandi (Ricerche sulla cronologia dei filosofi elienistici [Stuttgart 1991J 29f, 61, 69ff, 76), following J. Barnes (" Antiochus of Ascalon," in Griffin and Barnes [supra n.6J 51-96 at 68ff, esp.69 n.76), has recently argued on this basis and on the dating of Diogenes' pupils Panaetius, Mnesarchus, and Dardanus that Diogenes lived until ca 140, yielding a birthdate of ca 228.Thiery (supra n.1) 9-29 provides a survey of what is known of Diogenes' life.Diogenes came from Seleuceia-on-the-Tigris in the region of Baby lon-hence his ethnic (Strab.6.1.16;D. L. 6.81).9 On this embassy see 389-95 infra.Cicero (A cad.2.137) knew a book by Clitomachus that preserved details of the embassy and showed that Carneades argued a position (and attributed it to Diogenes) identical to that preserved in the text presented 366£ infra.Diogenes was Carneades' teacher in dialectic: Cic.Acad.2.98 (from Clitomachus).
Authors: Dirk Obbink, Paul A. Vander Waerdt
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W1601776838
