Work

Has Teacher Collective Bargaining Revolutionized American Public School Governance?--A Critical Review

Year: 1987
Type: article
Abstract: The historic collective bargaining agreement was reached between the New York City Board of Education and the United Federation of Teachers in 1962.By 1985 thirty-three states and the District of Columbia had granted teachers bargaining rights by law.2 Contracts are being negotiated in states that have passed mandatory bargaining laws as well as in others that have not.By the mid 1960's, some two hundred thousand public school teachers were covered by formal collective bargaining agreements.Currently, more than 1.7 million teachers, well over 60% of the nation's teachers are working under contracts negotiated between teacher union representatives and representatives of school district management.3Over the years a good deal of speculation has been expressed regarding the impact teacher collective bargaining has had or will have upon the governance of public schools at the local school district level.In its early days, teacher collective bargaining was viewed as a "coming revolution" in educational policy making that would enable teachers to become involved directly in the rnanagement of public elementary and secondary school systems.`It has been recently argued that collective bargaining by teachers has substantially altered the pattern of governance in school districts5 and that only desegregation and governmental aid programs to education have had a "comparable impact on the nature of schooling in America."6This paper examines the impact of teacher collective bargaining on the governance of public school systems, particularly at the local level.Before the impact can be discussed, however, it is first important to review the ideology and structure of governance in American schools in which teacher collective bargaining has been emerglng.embedded in locally controlled boards of education.While ptiblic education is fundamentally a function of the state, the state has delegated much of the power of governing public schools to local boards of education.Consequently, the people of the local community generally elect members of the boards, which then manage the affairs of school districts as the "legal focal center"8 of power in the structure of the local community.The school board assurnes the power to formulate major school policy, develop programs, hire and fire school personnel, decide the school budget, manage the physical facilities of the districts, and so on.9Thus, the board takes its responsibility with the ideology that `tthe final authority must rest with the lay board" and that "the schools belong to the people7"O Yet, in spite of a fundamental ideology of lay control of local school governance, the reality is different.The current form of public school governance is a product of a reform movement.At the turn of the century, when efficiency and scientific management were being stressed, a municipal reform movement emerged in urban centers around country.The reformers sought alternatives to word-based machine politics and the patronage system in order to manage city government scientifically, efficiently, systematically, and rationally.'iEducation was no exception because the school system was part of the municipal system that needed cleaning up and because the reformers sought to change the nature and source of educational control as part of their effort to improve municipal government.i2Lawrence Cremin vividly characterizes the era of political corruption pervasive in urban school systems : As school budgets mounted, politicians were quick to recognize one more lucrative source of extra income.... Teaching and administra-' • ' 70
Author: Haruo Ota
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1603234234
FWCI:
Cites: 14
Cited by:
Related to: 10