Work

Be(com)ing reel independent woman: An autoethnographic journey through female subjectivity and agency in contemporary cinema with particular reference to independent scriptwriting practice

Year: 2009
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Women exert only a modicum of production power in 21 st century cinema despite its growing accessibility and spectatorship through the developing technologies of the digital era.In 2007, of the top 250 grossing films in Hollywood, only 10% were written, and 6% directed, by women, and just 16% contained leading female protagonists.Why, after the gains of the film feminist movement, is there such a significant gender imbalance in mainstream film, and an imbalance that is only increasing over time?More significantly, what are the possibilities and limitations for reel woman's subjectivity and agency, in and on screen, in this male-dominated landscape?As a female filmmaker in this current climate I conduct an autoethnographical scriptwriting-based investigation into female subjectivity and agency, by writing the feature length screenplay Float, which is both the dramatic experiment and the creative outcome of this research.The exegesis works symbiotically with my scriptwriting journey by outlining the broader contexts surrounding women filmmakers and their female representations.In this self-reflexive examination, I use an interdisciplinary methodology to unravel the overt and latent sites of resistance for reel woman today on three interdependent levels.These comprise the historical, political and philosophical background to woman's treatment both behind, and in front of, the camera; my lived experiences as an emerging writer/director as I write Float; and my representation of the screenplay's central female character.I use the multiple logic of screenplay diegesis to explore the issues that have a bearing on women's ability to be active agents in the world they inhabit, including: the dichotomising of female desire, the influence of familial history, the repression of the mother, the dominance of the male gaze, the disavowal of female specificity, and women's consequent dislocation from their self-determined desire.These obstacles are simultaneously negotiated as I map my process of writing Float and deal with the challenging contexts in which the screenplay was created.In the course of my scriptwriting investigation, film feminist and French poststructuralist paradigms are considered and negotiated as I experiment whether it is possible for female filmmakers, and their female characters, to overcome the seemingly insurmountable odds facing women's actualisation today.My research brings to light the critical need for more inclusive modes of practice across the film industry, discourse and pedagogy that are cognisant and respectful of reel women's difference, and allow them to explore their own specificity.The thesis argues that it would be advantageous for female filmmakers to challenge their 'fixed' status in phallocentric discourse, and to deconstruct their patriarchal conditioning through engagement with forms of identity and writing resistance that recognise the fluidity of their subjectivity, and the consequent potential for change.I also highlight the importance of an accessible and affirmative feminist cinema pertinent to the 21 st century, to integrate feminist ideals into the mainstream, and finally bring reel woman out of the margins.Behar stresses that the 'vulnerable writing' employed in personal research "takes as much skill, nuance, and willingness to follow through on all the ramifications of a complicated idea as does writing invulnerably and distantly".15 In light of this counsel, and following her insistence that "[t]he exposure of the self who is also a spectator has to take us somewhere we couldn't otherwise get to.It has to be essential to the argument, not a decorative flourish", 16 I employ measures to try to ensure that the project's personal insights offer an opportunity to examine the culture of contemporary cinema, and woman's place within it, from an otherwise unattainable level of authenticity.In order to "not simply chronicle "what happened next," but place the "next" in a meaningful context", 17 I locate my autobiographical memories and lived experience within institutional, theoretical and phenomenological discourses to contextualise and analyse my research findings more scrupulously.This requires me to take up dual writing identities in this thesis, where I occupy shifting points of view.At times I put myself under the autobiographical lens: zooming in, seeing and revealing close up the secret-self desires that inform my scriptwriting; and at other times being forced to zoom out, to observe myself from an objective viewpoint, with a critical gaze, in a wide shot within a cultural scenery.18 Through this twofold investigation, I am then both the observer and the observed.This creative research project is literal as well as figurative, and I take the liberty of leading the reader through my carefree earlier years of simple childhood narratives, into the intricate and complex adult world of negotiating contradiction, difference, injustice, and desire as a female filmmaker.The project has been influenced and shaped by my independent scriptwriting practice, theoretical research, teaching in the areas of film and television, and by the regular conversations I have had with my supervisor, himself a (women) even when it is at pains to demonstrate the differences within this admittedly generalizing and imprecise category".38 Considering this, I would like to note here that I do not classify woman as a homogeneous entity and therefore do not presume to represent all female filmmakers in this autoethnographical research.I recognise women's cinematic experience can be highly disparate, dependent upon many factors including race, sexuality, and class.For this reason, while I do not mean to overlook or trivialise the works of, say, black or lesbian female filmmakers, or to construct a 'white, middle-class, heterosexual' canon for feminist cinema, in the contextual research for this thesis, I purposefully do not venture too far outside of my lived experience.This project joins a large and diverse culture of feminist cinema and discourse that equally informs the experiences and status of 'woman' in and on screen.Saying that, however, while I wish to respect these critical differences among female filmmakers, and acknowledge the need for multiple subjectivities within film feminism, I do believe that a selection of female-made films today share a voice of resistance: a commonality of subversive themes, and the reworking of conventional film techniques and constructions.I propose that this is most likely due to our mutual exclusion, as women, from the main power sources of film.Consequently, this collective difference to the prevailing framework of cinema can be used as a political strength.While my desire to undertake this journey into female filmmaking has more to do with necessity, curiosity, and personal agency than with an excess of feminist attitude, in this research I advocate notions of third wave feminism.These should not be confused with postfeminism, which I see as fundamentally conservative and capitalist in its agenda.How do the specific circumstances in which we write affect what we write?How does what we write affect who we become?55 Laurel RichardsonIn the beginning, there is an end.Don't be afraid: it's your death that is dying.Then: all the beginnings.56 Helene Cixous In Float's first draft I found myself writing about identity, language, trauma, death and family, through the story of Hannah, a young writer and English language teacher, recently diagnosed as HIV positive.This diagnosis caused significant conflict in Hannah's relationships with others, as she attempted to deny her mortality and withdraw into a private world of chaos and self-destruction.In particular, it became a catalyst for her to revisit painful memories regarding her mother's emotional absence throughout her life.The narrative saw Hannah form a bond with Martha, an elderly German woman in her English language class, who soon became Hannah's maternal substitute in her time of need.picture", 74 so as to remain open to the possibility that there might not be anything 'wrong' with us, per se, as individuals, "but rather something very wrong with the dynamics that dominate the communicative system" 75 within which we operate: in the case of this project, the wider community and the discourse of film.Narrative reframing required me to use my mutually informative positions as a female filmmaker; film tutor and lecturer; spectator and student to reflect on the broader ethnographical context of female subjectivity and agency in film.I wanted to analyse my gender construction, and the complex relationship between my scriptwriting praxis, and the personal, social and historical context within which it is produced.I therefore set out to deconstruct my lived experience as a reel woman: to investigate my familial, educative, and pedagogical history and culture, and their conditioning of my agency, so as to ascertain whether I could write a different future for myself, and for Hannah.Feminist psychologists Polly Young-Eisendrath and Florence Wiedemann (1987) advocate this autoethnographic approach, suggesting that: the experience of a relatively coherent female self is an ongoing project of consciousness building that encompasses a woman's personal history and the history of female identity in her society.76 Rich similarly validates this methodology in female filmmakers' pursuit of agency, asserting that, "[w]e need to begin analysing our own films, but first it is necessary to learn to speak in our own name".77 Pulling FocusThis project presents matters of personal and professional importance for reel women.Through both my praxis and pedagogy, I have come to learn more about the needs of female filmmakers who often experience considerable alienation in university film courses and the filmmaking industry, which, in their design, are still intrinsically Introduction 46 gendered institutions, encoded with phallocentr
Institution: Murdoch University
Language: English
Subfield: Gender Studies
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1606437594
Cites: 247
Cited by: 5
Related to: 10