Work

Portfolio disclosure, portfolio selection and mutual fund performance evaluation

Year: 2004
Type: preprint
Abstract: The paper sets up a model of delegated portfolio management where mutual funds differ with respect to the amount of their portfolio disclosure. Mutual funds may report their holdings only infrequently or incompletely, as is the case for most mutual funds in all industrialized countries. With incomplete portfolio disclosure fund investors face an informational handicap compared to fund managers. The reported holdings reflect only a noisy signal about the genuine managerial positions. The level of portfolio disclosure determines the transparency of mutual funds and so influences the amount of fund risk borne by fund investors. With incomplete portfolio disclosure, fund investors face two sources of fund risk: risk on stock returns and risk regarding the fund’s holdings. Since the portfolio strategies of fund managers reflect their private information, risk on fund holdings accounts for the investors’ uncertainty about managerial talents. Portfolio disclosure reduces risk on fund holdings. It has three major implications: First, it affects the composition of efficient managed portfolios. More frequent disclosure permits fund managers to respond stronger to their private information. Second, by reducing fund risk it improves, ceteris paribus, mutual fund performance. Third, it requires that performance measures have to be designed with respect to the portfolio disclosure of funds in order to reflect fund risk and performance appropriately. We modify widely used performance measures of Sharpe (1966) and Jensen (1968) to incorporate the level of portfolio disclosure of mutual funds. (JEL classification: G11, G23). Delegated portfolio management of mutual funds is characterized by informational asymmetry between fund managers and fund investors. Fund managers know their talents much better than fund investors do. They know precisely the positions they hold and why they trade, whereas fund investors have to infer managerial talents based only on the track record of fund returns and the information funds report on their holdings. The size of the informational handicap faced by fund investors is determined by the disclosure frequency of the fund. If fund managers report their holding more frequently, portfolio disclosure reflects the genuine portfolio strategy of the manager more accurately. With funds reporting their positions only at infrequent disclosure dates, fund investors face two sources of fund risk: risk on stock returns and risk with respect to the fund’s holdings. Since fund holdings reflect the portfolio strategy of the fund manager, risk on the fund holdings accounts for the fund investors’ uncertainty about managerial talent. Its size depends on two factors: the frequency of portfolio disclosure of the fund and the intensity of the fund manager’s trades. Both, more frequent disclosure and less intense trading increase transparency and so reduce fund risk. Our results have three major implications for delegated portfolio management. First, fund managers have to adapt their managed portfolios to the level of their portfolio disclosure. Fund investors, once observing the fund holdings and once not, bear different amounts of risk when investing in one and the same fund. Since optimal portfolios balance expected return Section 30(e) of the U.S. Investment Company Act of 1940 specifies that mutual funds must send semiannual shareholder reports to their investors containing a summary of their end-of-period holdings. Beside mandatory disclosure, many funds voluntary report their holdings more frequently. Wermers (1999) reports that in 1995 almost 60% of the regulated funds disclosed their holdings each fiscal quarter. Further on, many funds provide additional information about their contemporaneous top holdings or sector weightings on their websites. For example, Fidelity posts the end-of-quarter top 10 holdings and the end-of-month sector weightings of each of its funds on its website. Effective May 2004, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission increased the mandated disclosure frequency from semiannual to quarterly portfolio disclosure, reflecting the belief that fund investors benefit from more frequent portfolio disclosure through increased fund transparency. Managed portfolios are portfolios whose weights are not yet fixed but depend (in a prespecified way) on some information still to be received by the portfolio manager.
Language: English
Subfield: Finance
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1606683205
Cites: 25
Cited by: 4
Related to: 10