The Toughest Season in the White House : The Rhetorical Presidency and the State of the Union Address, 1953-1992
Year: 2014
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The present study explores the intersection of the institutional and the Rhetorical Presidency. By recognizing that the American presidency is an institution---an embodiment of the government---a researcher looks closely not only at the President as an individual, but also at the aggregate of people who co-create the institution. The Rhetorical Presidency marks the major transformation in the pattern of communication and governance of the US Presidents in the twentieth century. In consequence of that transformation, presidential speeches have, allegedly, routinized and the White House started to rely increasingly on professional wordsmiths, rather than policy experts for speechwriting. In addition, audible and visible aspects of presidential performance became more and more important. By reawakening attention to the State of the Union Address (Sotu)---the only constitutionally mandated communication between the President and Congress that was instrumental in the development of the President's legislative leadership---the present study seeks to explore whether and in what way the changes associated with the emergence of the Rhetorical Presidency may have affected, what Charles J. G. Griffin called, the speech writing infrastructure ---that is the people and procedures which were responsible for coordinating the State of the Union preparatory process under presidents: Dwight D. Eisenhower, John F. Kennedy, Lyndon B. Johnson, Gerald R. Ford and George H. W. Bush. Based on the analysis of archival materials pertaining to the processes of producing the Sotu during the above-mentioned presidencies, the present study challenges some generalizations attributed to the rise of the Rhetorical Presidency. By analyzing the involvement of policy experts, speechwriters, and the selected Presidents in the Sotu process, the present study throws light on the actual impact of the transformation in the pattern of communication on drafting and the presentation of the State of the Union Addresses. As most speeches nowadays are believed to be written as instant White House responses to issues and handed to the President on the way to the podium, the Sotu process requires deliberation of the entire government. In spite of the increasing specialization of the staff s functions, the President s success or failure is also shaped by his own efforts. In fact, the Presidents have become involved in activities that go beyond the scope of their formal constitutional powers and started to play an increasingly active role in all stages of the Sotu preparatory process, including drafting, an activity which with the rise of the Rhetorical Presidency is assumed to have become a domain of professional language experts or wordsmiths. A slight reversal in the overall trend was observed in the organization of the speechwriting infrastructure in the Bush White House. Also, in consequence of the shift to popular leadership, a further shift---beyond words---and towards visual leadership---took place. Modern leadership requires more than mere actions and words. Modern Sotus are designed to be heard, not read. Importantly, as LBJ s case illustrates, visual leadership remains complementary, yet inseparable, to legislative leadership. By emphasizing the rhetorical dimension of the office, the Rhetorical Presidency imposes demands on the presidency that contribute to making the Sotu preparatory process so time-consuming and convoluted---the toughest season in the White House. Keywords: State of the Union, rhetorical presidency, institutional presidency, speechwriting, speechmaking.
Author: Iwona Świątczak-Wasilewska
Language: English
Subfield: Communication
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: rhetorical presidency, State of the Union address, presidential rhetoric, speech writing, speechwriters, White House communications, presidential communication, legislative leadership, policy experts, Dwight D. Eisenhower, John F. Kennedy, Lyndon B. Johnson, Gerald R. Ford, George H. W. Bush, presidential performance
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1606784423
