Year: 1978
Type: article
Abstract: The received opinion that prefers an early age for the instruction of children in a second language has ifs sources in various long-established postulates from non-pedagogical fields. Genesee names them as the cogni-tive-nativist and neuropsychological positions, and the argument of "affective purity". He reviews each argument and cites some Irequently-heard objections, with a view to establishing a Iresh perspective on the issue belore inspecting some specilically educational research that bears upon it. By a careful weighing of the indications presently available, Genesee argues that advantage seems to lie with an early beginning followed by work at the secondary lev el. Considerable debate has arisen in Canadian educational circles concerning the optimal age for second language learning in school (see, for example, Stern, 1976; and Smythe, Stennett and Gardner, 1975). This is a debate which has recently become heated in discus-sions of various immersion methods of second language instruction where the advantages of early immersion in French are weighed against the advantages of so-called late immersion, and in discussions of starting dates for second language programs of the ESL or FSL type (English- or French-as-a-second language). Most of the research conducted to date that has investigated the issue systematically has involved an exarnination of the more traditional techniques such as those which characterize ESL and FSL approaches. l would like to continue discussion of this issue in this paper. Before doing so, there are two major restrictions to the discussion which l will impose. First, programs in which the target language of the students is also the native language of most other members of the school will not be considered; this includes for example, English children learning French in French schools, or so-called "submersion" programs. This means that consideration will be given only to pro-grams where the students ' native language is otherwise dominant. Second, program effectiveness will be defined in terms of second
Author: Fred Genesee
Institution: McGill University
Language: English
Subfield: Language and Linguistics
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W162274957
