Work

Migration of physicians and nurses: a world wide picture. 1978.

Year: 2004
Type: article
Abstract: INTRODUCTION The international flow of highly trained manpower has become a matter of mounting political concern. Its implications in regard to economic development and social equity within and between nations has been a constantly recurring item in the agenda of both national and international meetings. Debates have seldom been based on reliable data; they have more often been supported by only fragmentary information or mere speculation. Learned men have always travelled abroad seeking a more congenial intellectual milieu to realise their full potential. International exchange of scientific knowledge that results from the international mobility of skilled manpower is considered desirable. Today, there is concern about a migratory flow of a different kind--that of the elite from less prosperous countries flooding into a few privileged countries of the world; the alleged effect of such movement being the widening gap between the rich and the poor nations. This form of migration has in the past involved many professional groups. Over the past decade, however, the trends of such migrations show a decline for all professions except health manpower, in particular physicians and nurses, exacerbating the maldistribution of health care throughout the world. Such migration is not a universal phenomenon in that only relatively few countries are heavy donors of physicians and/or nurses, and even fewer are recipients. The enormous growth of the migration flows coupled with the lack of reliable data on its actual and potential effects has generated a great deal of anxiety. This is reflected in the multiplicity of literature on the subject and is also attested by the numerous resolutions adopted by the United Nations and related specialized agencies--resolutions which inter alia call for more information on the phenomenon and for measures to modify it in desirable ways. The international flow of physicians and nurses is a significant, currently unpredictable, and largely uncontrolled movement which manifests a high rate of change in terms of size and direction. Its unpredictability adds to the uncertainty in health manpower planning, particularly in the forecasting of future health labour requirements. THE WHO MULTINATIONAL STUDY Scope method and constraints The primary objective of the study was to identify a set of patterns of physician and nurse migration and to suggest, with respect to each pattern, alternative measures that could be considered to modify it. The instrumental objectives were, in summary, to define the characteristics of the migrants end the dimensions, directions, determinants and consequences of the flows. The attainment of the objectives of the study was to constitute a first essential component of a broader purpose, that of cooperation with countries that so request, in selecting and implementing strategies for dealing with the problems that either foster or result from the international migration of physicians and nurses. The attainment of this aim would, in turn, contribute to the formulation of realistic health manpower policies and plans. As originally designed, the study was to consist of three phases, with one phase being an analysis of societal factors, the next phase an analysis of health system factors and the last phase an analysis of personal motives, perceptions and characteristics of individual physicians and nurses. While a thorough understanding of world migration could well have resulted from the three-phased approach, it immediately became evident that anxiety evoked by migration had reached a peak in both major donor and recipient countries. It was. therefore, decided to streamline the study in the hope that its findings would be used in decision-making. As implemented the study was essentially based on existing published and unpublished information retrieved with the cooperation of WHO Member States. …
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1644451490
FWCI: 0.956
Cites:
Cited by: 25
Related to: 10