Work

Ethical debate: Doctoring malaria, badly: the global campaign to ban DDT DDT for malaria control should not be banned Commentary: Reduction and elimination of DDT should proceed slowly

Year: 2000
Type: editorial
Abstract: Ethical debate Doctoring malaria, badly: the global campaign to ban DDTThe treaty on persistent organic pollutants-POPs-will be finalised at the United Nations Environment Programme meeting in Johannesburg, 4-9 December.One proposal is to ban DDT, still used by many countries for controlling the mosquitoes that spread malaria.It should not be banned, argue Amir Attaran and Rajendra Maharaj, specialists in malariology and also international development and law-there's no evidence that spraying with DDT harms anyone.The issue is not straightforward, says Richard Liroff, director of the World Wildlife Fund's alternatives to DDT project; the treaty raises a series of equity challenges. DDT for malaria control should not be bannedAmir Attaran, Rajendra Maharaj Last year, deaths from malaria in Africa reached an all time high.Next year they will probably do so again, claiming around a million children.Yet in this deadly upward spiral, political pressure is building at the United Nations Environment Programme to pass a treaty by the end of 2000 to internationally ban or restrict one of the world's best anti-malarial tools.That tool is, of course, DDT-dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane.The campaign to ban it, joined by 260 environmental groups, reads like a who's who of the environmental movement and includes names such as Greenpeace, Worldwide Fund for Nature (WWF), and (ironically) the Physicians for Social Responsibility.Together, they are "demanding action to eliminate" DDT and its sources. 1 This view is stunningly naive.DDT residual house spraying is an inexpensive, highly effective, practice against malaria, and it has been approved by the World Health Organization.In it, trained sprayers apply a small quantity of DDT on the interior walls and eaves of homes in endemic regions.The quantities involved are minimal (2 g/m 2 ) and, unlike agricultural uses which inject tonnes of DDT into the outdoors, indoor house spraying results in little harmful release to the environment.For the amount of DDT used on a cotton field, all the high risk residents of a small country can be protected from malaria. 2 Few things compare for drama with an effective DDT spraying programme.In its heyday, DDT was successfully used to eradicate malaria from some nations (United States, Europe) and to lower case rates by over 99% in others (Sri Lanka, India).3 4 In South Africa it was used to eradicate the two most dangerous species of malaria mosquitoes, Anopheles funestus and A gambiae, from the country.All this saved millions of lives.So, if DDT can be this successful, why ban it?The latest campaign stems from charges that DDT is an "endocrine disrupter" whose ability to cause harm (like Melville's Moby Dick and all excellent monsters since) is both indiscriminate and vast.The World Wildlife Fund and Physicians for Social Responsibility indict DDT chillingly: as a carcinogen, a teratogen, an immunosupressant, and so on.5 6 All this would be worrisome if it were true.Conspicuously absent behind the campaigners' claims are any epidemiological studies to demonstrate adverse health effects.Although hundreds of millions (and
Source: BMJ
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W1647158468
Cites: 13
Cited by: 84
Related to: 9